Spotted owl debate. Northern spotted owls vs. timber 2022-10-03
Spotted owl debate
An argumentative essay is a type of essay that presents a clear and debatable claim or thesis statement, and then provides evidence to support the claim. The goal of an argumentative essay is to persuade the reader to agree with your perspective on a particular topic. In order to do this effectively, it is important to follow a specific structure and include certain elements in your writing.
The following is a template that can help guide you through the process of writing an argumentative essay:
Introduction: This is the opening section of your essay, where you should introduce the topic and provide some context for the reader. You should also state your thesis or claim clearly in this section.
Body paragraphs: These are the main sections of your essay, where you will present your arguments and evidence to support your claim. Each body paragraph should focus on a specific aspect of your argument, and provide concrete examples and evidence to support your points. Make sure to also address any counterarguments and refute them in your body paragraphs.
Conclusion: This is the final section of your essay, where you should summarize your main points and restate your thesis or claim. You should also conclude with a call to action or a recommendation for further action.
Here are some tips to keep in mind as you write your argumentative essay:
Use strong, clear language: Be sure to use strong, clear language to convey your points effectively. Avoid using jargon or technical language that may be difficult for the reader to understand.
Use credible sources: In order to support your arguments, you will need to use credible sources of information. Be sure to carefully research and choose reliable sources, such as academic journals, reputable news outlets, and government websites.
Use logical reasoning: Your arguments should be logical and well-reasoned, and should follow a clear line of thought. Use transitional words and phrases to connect your ideas and help the reader follow your argument.
Use rhetorical devices: Rhetorical devices, such as rhetorical questions, appeals to emotion, and repetition, can be effective in persuading the reader to see your perspective. Use these devices sparingly, however, as overuse can distract from your main points.
By following this template and keeping these tips in mind, you should be well on your way to writing a strong and persuasive argumentative essay.
Babbitt Supreme Court : At issue is the scope of the Department of the Interior's regulation that makes it illegal to harm endangered species by modifying its habitat. The scene was not exactly natural, however, as they were feeding at the town dump. Are there any other cases where humor was employed? If we can help people in the Third World, we can certainly help our own people. The spotted owl is considered an indicator species -- a gauge of the health of the ecosystem that provides its habitat. Once these trees have reached their maturity, most of their energy is spent simply maintaining themselves, rather than in new growth. The eyes are brown.
Why should an owl, whose habitat is a source of material needed for housing, be given special consideration? In the case of the spotted owl, we must ask whether and to what extent preserving endangered species and the wilderness they inhabit should take precedence over other considerations, such as major economic dislocations. Industry representatives claim that the measure will leave thousands of Northwest loggers and mill workers jobless, and insist that such protectionist policies thoughtlessly fail to take into account the dire economic consequences of preservation. A monkey wrench in the cogs of capitalism as Rush would have us believe? Timber employment did subsequently decline, by 14% compared to regional employment in the sector and by 28% in the impacted counties compared to the industry at the national level. Extinctions caused by the practices of humans, who are part of nature, are no more "unnatural" than extinctions caused by other predators. Weighing the Costs and Benefits From the environmentalists' perspective, the benefits of preserving the northern spotted owl and its habitat far outweigh any of the costs. Rampant lumbering and the growth of the logging industry were causing havoc to the old growth forests in the Northwest. Second, society ought to preserve this species and the unique ecosystem it represents because of their aesthetic value.
What is the spotted owl controversy?
First, saving the spotted owl will save an entire ecosystem on which plants, other animals, and humans depend. But, they argue, these jobs will vanish no matter what. It has an integrity and potentiality of its own, manifest in its unique stages of development and its intriguing adaption to the environment around it. Each subspecies of the spotted owl is a frequent subject of disagreement between 2 in Arizona, Utah, Colorado, and New Mexico as critical habitat for the owl. These estimates are significantly lower than the projections made by industry and align with federal projections 13,000 near-term jobs and 28,000 jobs in the long run. Journal of Sustainable Forestry.
Northern Spotted Owl Controversy
Fledged young give a similar high-pitched whistle to beg for food. Pace Environmental Law Review. We're down to a bare minimum. According to one report, if the volume of old growth declines, up to 28,000 jobs could be lost, leading to "increased rates of domestic disputes, divorce, acts of violence, delinquency, vandalism, suicide, alcoholism, and other problems. Verner, Jared; McKelvey, Kevin S. Until substitutes can be found, society has no choice but to rely on wood from old-growth forests.
Ethics and the Environment: The Spotted Owl
Anderson is the John and Jean DeNault Senior Fellow at the Hoover Institution. The logging industry was subjected to some very bad publicity as well when there were very little changes in place to support their initiative or rebellion. Under the multilayered canopies of these 200-year-old forests, the owl, known as the northern spotted owl, has fed off the rich plant and invertebrate life created by decaying timber and has nested in the cavities of old trunks. The hoots have a deep, pure tone, with females' voices higher than males. These reductions reflect a decline of about 32,000 jobs in the lumber and wood products sector when compared nationally, or 16,000 jobs when compared within the region. Fish and Wildlife Service to list the owl as an "endangered species," a move that would bar the timber industry from clearing these lands.
Spotted Owl Sounds, All About Birds, Cornell Lab of Ornithology
The studies found that in the absence of barred owls, the population of spotted owls did not decline, and were able to bounce back. The Mexican subspecies occurs in pine-oak forests, steep canyons, and mixed conifer forest. Half of Oregon's three million acres of old growth is not being logged because it has been designated as wilderness or is unsuitable for logging. Journal of Raptor Research. Why is the northern spotted owl important? The California subspecies lives in conifer forests as well as oak woodlands. In his announcement, he noted, "This achievement stands as one of America's great conservation successes; the culmination of decades of hard work and dedication on the part of the state, tribal, federal and private partners. And we also favor direct assistance.
Wildfires in Oregon, California Revive Debate Over Spotted Owl Protection
In 1988, nearly 4 billion board feet of raw logs were exported from Washington and Oregon. Roadblock strategies: Stark prohibiitons and their variability. Accipiter gentilis and crows may prey on juvenile spotted owls, while Bubo virginianus , Buteo jamaicensis , and Aquila chrysaetos are likely predators of both juveniles and adults. What do the technical reports say and how can you judge their validity? The program was sponsored by Sen. The ancient forests and the life they harbor form a complex web of interdependent relationships that play a critical role in preventing soil erosion, floods, and landslides, providing clean water for agriculture and cities, enhancing the productivity of salmon fisheries, enriching the soil with vital nutrients, and ameliorating the greenhouse effect. What other terms did the authors use to express the areas of habitat that were preserved or logged? It was due to this migratory phenomenon that had led to the banning of logging and restrictions were imposed on the lumber industry. The controversy over the northern spotted owl follows on the heels of debates over dolphins, whales, snail darters, and desert tortoises, each raising questions concerning society's obligation to protect animals threatened by extinction.
Northern spotted owls vs. timber
Center for Philosophy and Public Policy, "The Preservation of Species: Why Should We Care? However, the logging industry, the sawmill owners and those who were out of jobs did not take kindly to the situation and fuelled the Northern Spotted Owl controversy further. Ban to protect rare owls is lifted in Pacific Northwest. We slaughter cattle, pigs, and sheep to meet our needs. A Duty to Preserve Rare Species Some environmentalists counter that we also have an obligation to preserve species. But the towering cedars, firs, hemlocks, and spruces which have served as the owl's habitat, also have become a primary source of timber for a multi-billion dollar logging industry.
Ethics and the Environment: The Spotted Owl Controversy
Ruffled feathers in the forest. In 1986, a worried environmentalist group petitioned the U. Who knows what secrets these forests may hold? CSERC was one of numerous groups 20 years ago that helped achieve those policy changes. Clearcuts that were a common practice on Forest Service lands in the Sierra Nevada and the cutting of large, old trees were curtailed as science-based policies forced the USFS to shift to thinning logging and retention of big trees. Ted Gup, "Owl vs. Retrieved 10 January 2013. Bethesda, Maryland: The Wildlife Society.
As Northern Spotted Owl Debate Flares, New Insight on Job Impact, Threats
Hundreds of thousands of acres of old-growth forests, they argue, have already been set aside as national parks and wilderness areas. By Pete Danko As the Biden administration works to reverse Trump administration pullbacks in spotted owl habitat protection, two new peer-reviewed studies to inform the policy discussion have arrived. Rarity only intensifies the value of valuable things. The Craigheads' predictions proved true. Under this provision, timber companies are required to leave at least 40% of the old-growth forests intact within a 1.