Was george justified in killing lennie essay. Is George Justified For Killing Lennie (Of Mice and Men Book Analysis) 2022-10-21
Was george justified in killing lennie essay Rating:
In John Steinbeck's novella "Of Mice and Men," the character of George is faced with a difficult decision: whether or not to kill his mentally disabled companion Lennie. This essay will argue that, while George's actions may seem harsh, he was ultimately justified in his decision to end Lennie's life.
First and foremost, it is important to consider the context in which George found himself. Lennie was a liability to George, both physically and emotionally. Lennie's mental disability made it difficult for him to understand or control his own actions, and he often caused accidents or injuries as a result. For example, Lennie accidentally killed a puppy that George had given him to care for, and later on he accidentally kills Curley's wife. These incidents not only caused problems for George, but they also put Lennie in danger of being punished or even lynched by the other ranch hands.
In addition to the physical dangers posed by Lennie's disability, there was also the emotional burden that George carried as Lennie's caretaker. Lennie relied on George for nearly everything, and the responsibility of looking after him was a constant weight on George's shoulders. George had to constantly worry about Lennie's safety and well-being, and this took a toll on his own mental and emotional health.
Given these circumstances, it is understandable that George would want to find a way to end Lennie's suffering and his own. While killing Lennie may seem like a cruel and heartless act, it can also be seen as a mercy killing. Lennie was unable to live a normal life, and he was a constant source of danger and stress for those around him. By ending Lennie's life, George was able to spare him the suffering that would have inevitably come with his disability and the harsh realities of life on a ranch.
Furthermore, it is important to consider the time period in which the novella is set. In the 1930s, there were few options for caring for individuals with mental disabilities, and it was common for them to be institutionalized or even left to fend for themselves. While Lennie's death may seem tragic, it is possible that his life would have been even more difficult and unpleasant if he had been forced to live in an institution or on the streets.
In conclusion, while George's decision to kill Lennie may seem harsh and unforgiving, it was ultimately justified in the context of the circumstances he faced. George was faced with the difficult task of caring for a mentally disabled companion who posed a physical and emotional burden on him, and he made the difficult decision to end Lennie's suffering and his own. While this decision may not be one that everyone would make, it was a necessary and understandable choice for George given the circumstances.
Is George Justified In Of Mice And Men
Back then when someone wanted another person dead, they would hunt them down until they find them, and Curly was very mad at Lennie, and he was going to do anything… Mercy Killing In John Steinbeck's Of Mice And Men In summary, George made the correct decision by killing Lennie. At the very least, George would be thrown into jail and he due to his mental disability, he would not even comprehend the reason for his incarceration. That quote basically describes Lennie and George's relationship to each other. He killed Curley's wife by shaking her so hard her neck breaks. When he shot Lennie, it was like George had given up and had refused to protect his companion anymore.
The Great Depression made things worse for everyone, especially those without family or friends. After Lennie kills a young woman, George decides it is better for Lennie to be dead rather than to be tortured and kept in a cell or a mental asylum. He did it for the right reasons and it was best for Lennie in that situation. He decided persuaded by other people that the dog was no longer fit to live and had an acquaintance kill the dog for him. George decides to shoot him solely out of love for his friend, but this killing initiates a debate in which the readers can take sides about his righteousness. So, they didn't care how bad they would hurt him.
How Did George Kill Lennie Justified In Of Mice And Men
The alternative situation would have been severely worse in Lennie's case, and for George to watch. He will also do anything George or what most others would tell him to do. Along with this, George made sure to tell Lennie that he was never mad at him. That is why he did what he did. Yet George and Lennie was best friends, George made up his mind of what he had to do. George took care of Lennie for a while, and he still loves Lennie.
. When the other guys show up, Slim comes down to George and tells him that he had too. Curley—a mean, petty person who resents Lennie for being bigger and stronger than he is—has gathered a posse of men to lynch Lennie and make him suffer in revenge for killing his wife. Through Slim justifying the doctrine of double effect, we realise how practicalities can take precedence over. George tried to help him at all times as far as he could, but still Lennie was still in serious trouble, that 's precisely the reason why George wanted to prevent Lennie suffering in the future because he realized that he could not live alone.
Was George’s Decision to Kill Lennie the Right One?
Lennie was a brobdingnagian man. The author, John Steinbeck, shows the friendship of George and Lennie in several ways. George is justified in killing Lennie because he is already being punished enough mentally. The only way to protect Lennie was to kill him before anyone else could. I'm going for my shotgun. With all of George How Did George Kill Lennie Justified In Of Mice And Men 667 Words 3 Pages In Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck many hard decisions were made. George should have taught Lennie how to control himself when he was little.
When George was with all the men in the barn after discovering the dead body of Curly's wife he could hear all of them especially Curly… Of Mice and Men: Why George killed Lennie the Explanation There are some bad things in the world that we have to take action with; like dangerous dogs or bad people. George always talks to Lennie about how fabulous they are when they are together at their own ranch and from day to day I end up with their life in a very cruel way. He could have simply taken him back to the farm and let him live out his days there. He shows how George and Lennie care for one another, support one another in striving for their dream, and last but not least, by telling how they both make sacrifices and are responsible for one another. . George was justified in killing Lennie because Lennie was careless and dangerous.
Was George Justified In Killing Lennie Research Paper
Because of his mental disability, Lennie has a tactile deficiency and likes to pet soft things to help calm. I feel one reason why George was unjustified in shooting lennie Why George Is Not Justified In John Steinbeck's Of Mice And Men to explain why George is not justified in shooting Lennie. I'll kill the big son-of-a-bitch myself. . For his own benefit, George is compelled to kill Lennie.
Why Is Lennie's Death Justified In conclusion, George killing Lennie was a murder because of lack of consent and Lennie was not suffering physically. A silent head and beak lanced down and plucked it out by the head, and the beak swallowed the little snake while its tail waved frantically. . Not to mention Lennie was a strong. After he looked at Lennie and the others found him, he tried to convince himself that this was the right thing to do. Before George shot Lennie, he told Lennie about their dream.
. Lennie and george have been traveling together ever since lennie's aunt clara died, she asked george to watch after lennie because he's not that intelligent and he gets himself into quite a lot of trouble on his own. Also, not only did this decision free Lennie from misery. . In the story Lennie has a fascination with feeling soft objects. However, some critics argue that George could have found another solution. The contrast between George and Lennie becomes apparent in their conversation about their dream.