A world lit only by fire review. Godflesh: A World Lit Only By Fire review 2022-10-06

A world lit only by fire review Rating: 7,9/10 1415 reviews

"A World Lit Only by Fire" is a book written by William Manchester, first published in 1992. It is a historical examination of the Middle Ages, covering a wide range of topics including the fall of the Roman Empire, the rise of feudalism, the impact of the Vikings and Magyars, the Norman Conquest, and the Crusades.

One of the main themes of the book is the way in which the Middle Ages were a time of great transition and upheaval. Manchester argues that the period was marked by violence, insecurity, and uncertainty, as feudal lords and other powerful figures struggled for power and influence. At the same time, he also highlights the many cultural and intellectual achievements of the era, such as the development of the Romanesque and Gothic styles of architecture, the proliferation of monasteries and universities, and the emergence of great works of literature and art.

One of the most interesting aspects of "A World Lit Only by Fire" is the way in which Manchester brings to life the many different figures and events of the Middle Ages. He uses a wide range of primary sources, including chronicles, letters, and other documents, to provide a rich and detailed picture of the period. He also does an excellent job of putting these events into context, explaining the broader social and political forces at work and the ways in which they shaped the course of history.

Overall, "A World Lit Only by Fire" is a fascinating and thought-provoking book that offers a vivid and engaging portrayal of the Middle Ages. It is a must-read for anyone interested in this important period of history and the many ways in which it has shaped the world we know today.

A WORLD LIT ONLY BY FIRE

a world lit only by fire review

A sad collection of assumptions and half-baked pronouncements, with no real insight to be gained. What then is there left to read about in this book. The book gets better after the first part but I think it, as all history, should be taken with a grain of salt. Inconsistencies and half truths make for an interesting narrative, but not a good history. After a dozen pages I got the point that at the highest levels sexual immorality and killing of opponents were rampant. Men who do the remarkable — heroic and otherwise — frequently fail in their personal relationships. Turn "Obeyed" up extra-loud if you haven't already , and what sounds like Tuvan throat singing haunts the scourged background.


Next

childhealthpolicy.vumc.org: Customer reviews: A World Lit Only by Fire: The Medieval Mind and the Renaissance

a world lit only by fire review

Pure and unforgiving, this is what Godflesh had to bring to the world, for us and for themselves. Nevertheless, his deed, bering impulsive is actually unheroic. No punches are pulled, and no confession is respected. People view nature in unique ways that are displayed through actions and words. Every time I mentioned reading a book about the Middle Ages, this title seemed to come up, so off to the library I went. .

Next

Godflesh

a world lit only by fire review

I'm no expert on the Middle Ages and the early Renaissance but I remember enough from college courses taken a millennia ago to know that this book has problems. Intellectual thought and innovation were non existent. Still, updating the old notion that the Earp myth is the American Iliad, the author is at his best when he delineates those fraught spasms of violence. . Manchester seems to have a great reverence for Magellan and views him as emblematic of the new type of man that obliterated medieval complacency. On the other side, the Catholic counter-Reformation and the Inquisition became infamous for their wide-spread practices of torture and murder of anyone suspected of being a heretic or a Jew. I suggest this reading for those who need to write a research paper, suffer from insomnia or for some strange reason interested in the Middle Ages or the beginnings of the Catholic church.

Next

Review: Godflesh, 'A World Lit Only By Fire' : NPR

a world lit only by fire review

He devotes very little space in his 300 pages to it and the only thing I took away from it was that apparently peasants worked naked. It is particularly reprehensible that Manchester unquestioningly accepts scholarship that is invariably two or three generations old. What was gained and lost as the Renaissance dawned on the horizon; and also, there are interesting inferences that can be drawn, appropriate for modern times, on other areas of the world, where revelation rather than reason, alas, still holds sway. Also he's a believer in the Great man view of history also pretty old hat since behind every great man are the toilers who made all his discoveries possible and the events which allowed him to express his greatness. I liked how the book ended. If we look at earth for Roberts soldier side. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon.

Next

A World Lit Only by Fire

a world lit only by fire review

Heroism is the exact opposite — always deliberate, never mindless. Should've stopped at the get-go. And the idea of writing a history book that spans about 1200 years without picking up a primary source is, honestly, kind of reprehensible to me. . The historical accuracy of this book is to be strongly questioned and doubted. I found this intriguing and went online to learn more -- I found a "Straight Dope" column that refuted Manchester's speculation.

Next

a world lit only by fire

a world lit only by fire review

Only in the last few decades has the recreation of early music been taken up with academic rigor. . This book attempts to cover a lot of ground. The result is a collection of gruesome stories, stupid generalizations, platitudes that have been around for decades for instance about the obscurity of medieval thinking and so on. To some it's s'mores, to others it's destruction. Unfortunately it ultimately skewers itself on its biases. From the graph I found on Wiki it shows a tiny number of patents in the 1830's - 1850's.

Next

Godflesh: A World Lit Only By Fire review

a world lit only by fire review

I have an interest in medieval European history, as well as intellectual history more broadly, and the title sounded promising. The Renaissance man wanted to be unique, to stand out, to be different and to make an impression on others. The title itself comes from a quote on page 199: "In that age the world was still lit only by fire. I did learn a lot about Martin Luther and Magellan — who has the hero status in the book — but was frequently disconcerted by the tone and authorial voice. I wondered if it was written fast to gain the popular reader who wants sensational history with a large dose of "We're so much smarter, we moderns.

Next

A World Lit Only by Fire: The Medieval Mind and the Renaissance: Portrait of an Age by William Manchester

a world lit only by fire review

Then, there are logical "errors. Back to the book. This is not one of the former, but definitely it is one of the latter. Fair enough, he produced what I think was a good book that got you thinking about the subject he was presenting. The first part of the book introduce us to a new perspective and understanding of what the author believe, thanks to his investigations, form and mold the medieval mind. My favorite part: knowing that prostitutes were the cleanest people of their time, probably the only thing I will remember. I am not sure why all biographies don't become a record of an age, in fact of all Magellan in Context Manchester starts off writing a biography of Magellan, but in his attempt to put a context to his life, motivations and adventures, ends up expanding his scope until some six centuries of the medieval period are swallowed up by the story.


Next