Was louis riel a hero. Louis Riel: A Hero Or Villain? 2022-10-23
Was louis riel a hero Rating:
Louis Riel is a controversial figure in Canadian history, and opinions on whether he was a hero or not vary widely. Some see Riel as a hero who fought for the rights of Indigenous peoples and the French-speaking Métis community in Canada, while others view him as a traitor who instigated violence and rebellion against the Canadian government.
One argument in favor of Riel as a hero is that he stood up for the rights and interests of the Métis and Indigenous peoples in Canada, who were often marginalized and mistreated by the government and the dominant Anglo-Canadian society. Riel was a leader in the Red River Rebellion of 1869-70, which was sparked by the Canadian government's attempt to annex the Métis-majority region of Red River (now part of Manitoba) without consulting the local population. Riel and other Métis leaders formed a provisional government to resist the annexation and negotiate with the Canadian government for better terms. Riel also played a key role in the North-West Rebellion of 1885, in which he and a group of Indigenous and Métis fighters took up arms against the Canadian government in protest of its policies towards Indigenous peoples.
Another reason why Riel might be seen as a hero is that he was a visionary and a man ahead of his time. Riel was a devout Catholic and a deeply spiritual man who believed in the value of education and the importance of preserving Indigenous and Métis cultures. He also had progressive ideas about democracy and political representation, and he fought for the establishment of a just and fair society in which all people were treated with dignity and respect. Riel's ideas and actions inspired many people, and he is remembered as a pioneer and a champion of social justice in Canada.
However, there are also valid arguments against Riel as a hero. Riel's actions during the Red River Rebellion and the North-West Rebellion resulted in violence and death, and he was ultimately convicted of treason and executed by the Canadian government. Some see Riel as a reckless and divisive figure who instigated unnecessary conflict and brought suffering upon his followers. Additionally, Riel's mental health has been called into question, and some have argued that he was not fully in control of his actions and should not be held fully responsible for the consequences of his rebellion.
In conclusion, whether Louis Riel was a hero or not is a matter of perspective. While he stood up for the rights of Indigenous and Métis peoples and had visionary ideas about democracy and social justice, his actions also resulted in violence and conflict. Ultimately, it is up to each individual to decide whether Riel's contributions outweigh his mistakes, and whether he should be remembered as a hero or not.
Louis Riel was no hero
Terrified and worried because of that incident, Louis Riel escaped to the United States in 1870 when the Metis needed him the most. Throughout every aspect of his life including his personal life, business approach, and his philanthropy show that he was not a hero. When he was hung he refused to depict himself as insane as he thought it would be insulting to his followers, again, showing he had passion for his people and was willing to die for them. While he saw the abolition of slavery as moral progress, he stereotyped the moral state of blacks as being that of obedience and a warm-hearted disposition and did not want to grant them anything. Argumentative Essay: Is Frankenstein A Hero? For this is what Canada did to Riel; this is what Canada has done to us as a people. This act enabled the government to turn him into an outlaw, and he fled the settlement in August 1870 Manitoba Historical Society. They manipulate the powerless to stay in their position.
His Is Andrew Carnegie A Hero? Andrew Carnegie: Heroic Or Hero? He was also a leader of the Metis and Red River territory. He has done many wrong and unjust things in these parts of his life they prove that he was not heroic. Though Louis Riel actions were in the favor of the protection of the justice for the Métis his actions went against the British demand and violated his allegiance to the British; deeming Louis riel as a traitor. The Métis bill of rights concluded that the Métis would have the same rights as other nations. Riel knew that Métis were considered only half-breed and because of their half Indian half French nature they were considered to be less significant amongst the British. Louis Riel Research Paper 574 Words 3 Pages But the question is, was Louis Riel really a villain? Louis Riel was the leader in the 2 rebellions. He then left Montana with his family to go to South Branch in July 1884.
Louis Riel's Uprising: The North-West Uprising 917 Words 4 Pages Louis Riel became fed up with the Canadian government. Andrew Jackson was a villain not a hero. In addition, Groarke 2013 wrote of the defences Riel raised in his speech to the jury. And it must not be forgotten, hidden or denied The Royal Canadian Geographical Society acknowledges that its offices are located on the unceded territory of the Algonquin Peoples, who have been guardians of, and in relationship with, these lands since time immemorial. Riel made their first move, and established a provisional government in Fort Garry and remained loyal to it even when it was being hounded by the settlers of Ontario. Though some might think he is a traitor, disturbed the society. As an anointed prophet from God — and with a sizeable following who believed this to be so — Riel expected to triumph in what would become the North West Rebellion.
It should be noted that Riel himself never carried arms University of Saskatchewan. Why Is Christopher Columbus Considered A Hero 498 Words 2 Pages Almost everybody has heard of Christopher Columbus, but do you know that he tried to sail for 15 years. Get Help With Your Essay If you need assistance with writing your essay, our professional essay writing service is here to help! In February of 1870, the French and English communities each elected 20 representatives to the provisional government, with Riel as president. Just four years later, he seizes the arsenal at the Harpers Ferry, take weapons from there, and destruct many properties of the town. He influenced many people and philosophers, including Thomas Paine and Thomas Louis Riel's Effect On Canadian History 86 Words 1 Pages Louis Riel's execution has had a long lasting effect on Canadian history.
Was Louis Riel a hero or a childhealthpolicy.vumc.org
These illegal acts were not acceptable and in the end, he got hung up from these acts of Louis Riel Martyr 869 Words 4 Pages In my opinion Louis Riel is a martyr because of the things he did for his beliefs. The infamous Louis riel stood in the way of the national policy led by SJAM. This event led the government to see Louis Riel as a national villain and brand him as a traitor against British Crown. A few years later, Riel would be placed inside a mental institution by his Uncle after several examples of a deteriorating mental health condition, including claiming himself a prophet, giving away riches to a blind beggar, crying and shouting in public, and interrupting catholic mass to interrupt the priest University of Missouri-Kansas. I disagree, I believe that he was not a hero but a robber baron.
Find Out How UKEssays. One of the most famous Canadians of all time is Louis Riel. His name was William McDougall. This government negotiated on an agreement which allowed the territory surrounding the Red River Settlement to be able to enter the province of Manitoba. A key aspect discussed today is why Riel is a hero to his people; the Métis. He made a list of rights for Metis individuals some of which include the right to elect legislature, all sheriffs, magistrates and etc be elected by the people, all documents and acts of legislature be published in both french and english, etc. Samuel de Champlain is primarily known for founding the city of Québec in the year 1608, and for exploring and mapping the Great Lakes as well.
Louis Riel An Innocent Hero Or Deviant Villain History Essay
Knowing a portrayal of him being insane would make a negative impact to them. Louis Riel should be seen as a hero because he stood up for the rights of the Metis to the Canadian government during the Red River Settlement. I have a picture of my father from about 1939. Heroics that are played out after an act of violence are actions that do not allow for planning Eagly, 2013. More about Who Was Louis Riel A Hero? The Metis, French, and First Nations. This revolution fueled the Nationalist fire that many Quebecois had found when they feared for their culture and language throughout Canada 's history such as the conscription crisis in both World War One and Two, and when Ontario 's Louis Riel Case Study 1396 Words 6 Pages The major defence that was brought forward was deeming the man insane and incapable of comprehending the difference between right and wrong.
But some of the deeds that he did, had a purpose behind them. He is absolutely the most complex, the most dispute, the most pathos but an important person in the Canadian Louis Riel: A Hero Or Villain? With numerous opinions about who he was, it is up to the reader to choose their ideas of who he was. Louis Riel introduced another crucial development for the Métis; the Métis bill of rights. Riel was against the allegations and was determined to pledge his own case that he was sane and his actions were justified in order to gain rights for the Métis people. However, it is undeniable that he brought prosperity towards the people of the northwest, and was a genuine political figure in three ways; Riel proved his liability by creating a movement, giving the people a voice, and defending their way of life. Hero Or Villain: Andrew Jackson 716 Words 3 Pages Hero or Villain: Andrew Jackson Andrew Jacksons presidenicy was very complicated.