Cons of drug testing in high school. Pros and Cons of Drug Testing in Schools 2022-10-15
Cons of drug testing in high school Rating:
Drug testing in high schools has become a controversial topic in recent years, with some arguing that it is a necessary measure to ensure the safety and well-being of students, while others argue that it is a violation of privacy and civil liberties. In this essay, we will explore some of the cons of drug testing in high schools, highlighting the potential negative consequences and drawbacks of this policy.
One of the main arguments against drug testing in high schools is that it violates students' privacy and civil liberties. Many people believe that drug testing amounts to an invasion of privacy, as it requires students to provide a sample of their bodily fluids or hair for analysis. This can be embarrassing and uncomfortable for students, and some may feel that it is a violation of their personal rights. Additionally, some argue that drug testing may be prone to false positives, leading to innocent students being wrongly accused and punished.
Another con of drug testing in high schools is that it can create a climate of distrust and suspicion among students. When students are required to undergo drug testing, it can create a sense of mistrust between them and school officials, as they may feel that they are being unfairly targeted or treated with suspicion. This can lead to a breakdown in the relationship between students and school officials, which can have negative impacts on the school community as a whole.
Furthermore, drug testing in high schools may not be effective in achieving its intended goals. Some studies have shown that drug testing does not significantly reduce drug use among students, and may even have the opposite effect by driving drug use underground and making it more difficult to detect. This can lead to increased risk-taking behavior and potentially more dangerous consequences for students.
Another potential downside of drug testing in high schools is the cost. Implementing a drug testing program can be expensive, requiring the purchase of testing kits, hiring additional staff to administer the tests, and paying for laboratory analysis. This cost may be difficult for some schools to bear, particularly those with limited resources.
In conclusion, while drug testing in high schools may be well-intentioned, it can also have several negative consequences and drawbacks. It can violate students' privacy and civil liberties, create a climate of distrust, and may not be effective in reducing drug use. Additionally, the cost of implementing a drug testing program can be a significant burden for some schools. While it is important to address drug use in schools, it is also important to consider the potential consequences and drawbacks of drug testing policies before implementing them.
Drug Testing In A High School Setting: Pros And Cons Argumentative Essay Example
The state supreme court ruled random testing unconstitutional when it comes to search and seizure laws, notes the ACLU. How Common Is It? The study, The Effectiveness of Mandatory-Random Student Drug Testing, examined 7 districts that were awarded grants in 2006 by the U. Mandatory drug testing for high school athletes should be required because it decreases drug use in schools, is relatively inexpensive, and can prevent drug use and or abuse that can lead to a lifelong addiction. How many high schools have mandatory drug testing? The Cost of Testing With schools across the country tightening their budgets, the added expense of drug testing can be daunting for struggling school systems. Students should be tested because playing a sport opens lots opportunities and the government supports it.
It may lead to unnecessary privacy violations or result in families taking legal action. There could be further complications still if it is being used as a prescribed substance as a treatment of some type of disability, yet it is used as a disqualifier for employment. Hence, high school athletic programs are typically viewed as an aid to deter and to detect use. Schools are only legally allowed to randomly test students who take part in competitive sports and clubs, according to the National Institute on Drug Abuse. The harm reduction model looks at the societal factors that increase the chances that drug use could become a problem, including harsh punishments in the criminal justice system. Linn State Technical College LSTC , a small college in rural Missouri, broke this. Employers must write to the Connecticut labor commissioner to explain why they want to perform random drug tests and get approval for the program.
Such protection is vital to the privacy protection of all citizens from unacceptable conduct on the part of the government or its officers or agents. Privacy — the fundamental issue At the heart of drug-testing controversy in schools, however, is not efficacy but privacy. The larger the population, more controls have to added to help keep them safe. Adults need to step up and approach student athletes about the danger of the impact it can have on their life. Overall, PEDs have negative effects and foster a bad environment in sports. Taking for example the scenario that happens in schools, if a student is paranoid about drug testing but is sure to be clean, he or she should not hesitate on being under a test because a negative result will surely come out.
Isotope Ratio Mass Spectrometry IRMS is a relatively new technique that is being proposed for verification of testosterone positives. Both lifetime users and recent users were older than the non-users. A look at the facts provides a clearer picture about the benefits and problems associated with student drug testing. Order custom essay Drug Testing in a High School Setting: Pros and Cons with free plagiarism report Drug testing is part of a much wider picture. In… Drug Testing Athletes Essay enhancing drugs used by athletes to help them build muscle and perform outstandingly. Abusive usage of drug may lead to severe cases of mental health and other risky consequences that are dangerous for a person Pohlman et al.
Pros And Cons Of Drug Testing For High School Athletes
It is possible that drug testing in public schools could happen. Employers should also be aware of local laws. That said, if a student has illegal substances or is behaving as if she is under the influence, she can be tested. How has your organization combated these potentially negative issues when implementing a drug testing program as a condition of employment? If drug testing will not be made, it might cause severe cases in the future and might ruin the life of a student. The long-term benefits outweigh the initial cost of the testing. This will enable you to make a much more informed decision about the topic and to know more about the main points of each side for and against.
Another con would be that there are possibilities that the Standardized Testing And Creativity Overtesting is slowly defeating the purpose of school and learning in general. Many students have love Essay On Performing Enhancing Drugs Performing Enhancing Drugs and the World of Sports Sports has become one of the most impactful and influential parts of our culture. Employers must provide a safe work environment, and they want to ensure their employees are productive, but is maintaining a drug-testing program in furtherance of these goals worth the hassle? Mandatory drug testing for high school athletes should be required because it decreases drug use in schools, is relatively inexpensive, and can prevent drug use and or abuse that can lead to a lifelong addiction. By: Jane Schwab There is an interesting proposal that allegedly comes with certain safeguards in place to provide checks and balances to ensure there is no profiling or prejudices when it comes to the idea of drug testing in schools. When I reached high school age something that was always drilled into me by my coaches was the aspect of hard work. The Court also said that since athletes can be role models, it is especially important to be sure that they do not use drugs.
Under the community connection model, addiction is viewed primarily as a problem of lost connections to community rather than a sin, a disease, or a societal issue. Singling out athletes by having them drug tested is a problem when funding is insufficient, it violates the Fourth Amendment, and can be inaccurate. However, enough reason is needed before the conducting drug tests for a specific student just like for example having suspicious actions, having red eyes and the like. The disease model also advocates for complete abstinence as a means of getting relief from this incurable, deadly affliction. Evidence Leans Towards Effectiveness Random drug testing in schools is intended to curb illicit drug use, but the question remains: is it even effective? Drug abuse prevention programs on college campuses should be multidisciplinary and involve the entire campus and surrounding community environment in which students live and learn. When it comes to public schools, money can always be an issue.
Among the more controversial solutions to help protect children against foreign entities invading the education a facility, teachers and school administers want to have access to drug testing for students. What is the role of school in preventing drug abuse? The study found that of the districts with drug-testing policies, almost all tested athletes, and 65 percent targeted all students in extracurricular activities. The National Center for Education Evaluation reports that students involved in extracurricular activities in schools that conducted drug testing had less substance use than comparable students from schools without drug testing. I will be giving you Zero-Tolerance In Sports The life of a professional athlete is a pinwheel spinning in the wind. Each student from kindergarten to twelfth grade would need to be drug tested at the time they are admitted into school at the beginning of their school year.
Public schools are state actors; thus, the constitutional protections apply with respect to students and employees of public schools systems. According to a report at the National Institute of Drug Abuse, testing can be done as a deterrent for drug use. If they fail a drug test, they may be referred for treatment, suspended, or removed from the job. Withdrawals from anabolic steroids can result in depression and in some cases, suicide. The technology of drug testing has made significant advances; at the same time, cheating methods have also evolved and grown more sophisticated. Disadvantages On the other hand, disadvantages of mandatory testing are eyed to the fact that the right to privacy is violated.