How is the constitution a bundle of compromises. What Is The Constitution A Bundle Of Compromises 2022-10-15
How is the constitution a bundle of compromises Rating:
The United States Constitution is a document that outlines the laws and principles that govern the nation. It is a document that has been amended and amended again over the years, reflecting the changing needs and values of the country. At its core, however, the Constitution is a bundle of compromises. These compromises were necessary to bring together the diverse group of states and people that make up the United States, and they continue to shape the way that the country is governed to this day.
One of the most significant compromises in the Constitution was the Great Compromise, also known as the Connecticut Compromise. This compromise was reached during the Constitutional Convention of 1787, and it helped to resolve the disagreement between the small states and the large states over representation in Congress. The small states were concerned that they would be outvoted by the larger states in the new federal government, while the large states were worried that they would be overpowered by the smaller states. The Great Compromise resolved this disagreement by creating a bicameral legislature, with the House of Representatives based on population and the Senate equally representing each state. This compromise allowed the small states to have a greater say in the federal government, while also giving the larger states a greater influence through their larger representation in the House.
Another important compromise in the Constitution was the Three-Fifths Compromise, which dealt with the issue of slavery. During the Constitutional Convention, the southern states argued that they should be allowed to count their slaves as part of their population for the purpose of representation in Congress. The northern states, on the other hand, opposed this idea because they believed that it would give the south too much power in the federal government. The Three-Fifths Compromise was ultimately reached, which allowed the southern states to count three-fifths of their slave population for representation in Congress, but not for taxation purposes. This compromise helped to maintain a balance of power between the north and the south, but it also had significant consequences, as it helped to entrench slavery in the United States and ultimately contributed to the Civil War.
There were also many other compromises in the Constitution, including the Commerce and Slave Trade Compromise, which prohibited Congress from interfering with the international slave trade for a period of 20 years, and the Electoral College Compromise, which established the system for electing the President and Vice President. These compromises, and others like them, helped to bring the diverse states and regions of the United States together and create a more cohesive and functional federal government.
In conclusion, the Constitution is a bundle of compromises that were necessary to bring together the various states and people that make up the United States. These compromises have shaped the way that the country is governed, and they continue to have an impact on the country today. While some of these compromises, such as the Three-Fifths Compromise, have had negative consequences, they were necessary to create a balanced and functional federal government that could represent the needs and interests of all the states and regions of the country.
Why is our constitution called "a bundle of compromises?"
The Northern states wanted slaves counted as part of the population for representation in the House but not as part of the voting population for tax bills and revenue measurements. Another key compromise was the choice of the president. It is hard to say where the country goes without that compromise, but it is hard to see it going worse. The senate allowed represenation by state, and the house established repersentation by population. Eh, have you -read- the founding fathers? The convention was sent home and the Constitution was sent to the individual states for ratifying. It now consisted of the House of Representatives and the Senate.
How Was the Constitution a Bundle of Compromises Term Paper
But he was entirely too sure of himself during the campaign. Above, the being, apparently non-human, and dead, is ready for the autopsy to proceed, at a Dallas,. The details of the Virginia plan included the set up of two houses, membership determined proportionally, lower house elected by the people, upper house elected by the lower house, an executive was in power but would only exist to ensure the legislature will was carried out, forms of judiciary, an executive and judiciary would have the power to veto legislation and also a national veto of any state legislation. Do you need some more plagiarism-free essays? Therefore, the "small-state plan" was proposed, emphasizing equal representation from all states. The first chamber would be the House of Representatives, where each state would be represented based on population. It called for three branches; including a legislative branch comprised of two houses. Constitution called a bundle of compromises? This system would ensure that no one branch could become too powerful and take over the government.
This plan however created a problem because it did not settle well with the smaller states. Allowing slavery merely set up the civil war. . Okay, so Bob Corker is saying he wants it, but he will vote against it because it isnt paid for, yet he will vote for tax cuts that aren't paid for. It all started in 1850, when the compromise was presented. The compromise created two chambers in Congress, the Senate comprised of two senators representing each state while the House of Representations, contained state representatives based on their populaces. The Constitution… A Bundle of Compromises ISSUE SIDE A SIDE B COMPROMISE Representation Small states wanted all states to have the same number of representatives to Congress Large states wanted representation to be determined by the population of the state The Great Connecticut Compromise: the constitution creates a bicameral legislature.
Why was the U.S. Constitution called a bundle of compromises?
Whether the argument flies with you or not doesn't matter. So no, he didn't lie. . How does that resemble the Great Compromise, in your view? Delegates were concerned about how their state would be represented in a newly independent nation. The Great Compromise as it later became known started of with an agreement formed about the Virginia plan. The settlement reached saw the call for the abolition of this trade shelved until 1808, the introduction of ten dollars taxation on each imported slave, and an agreement that the Northern states would repatriate slaves who fled. After months of deliberation at the Constitutional Convention in Pennsylvania, a Constitution was ratified and agreed upon by the states.
Why Is The Constitution Called A Bundle Of Compromises, Essay Sample
It also required that all commerce legislation be passed by a two-thirds majority in the Senate, which was a win for the South since it countered the power of the more populous Northern states. Compromise, however, means that everyone gets less than they want. The Northern states wanted Congress to elect the president, while the Southern states wanted state legislatures to elect the president. This was a controversial issue because the Southern states wanted their slaves to be counted as citizens, while the Northern states wanted them to be counted as property. This disagreement led to the Three-Fifths Compromise, which stated that for representation in the House of Representatives and for tax bills and revenue measurements, each slave would be counted as three-fifths of a person. It may not be a "fair" compromise where both sides met in the middle but that doesn't mean there wasn't compromise.
The Constitution A Bundle of Compromises childhealthpolicy.vumc.org
Rather of being elected directly by the people, this president would be chosen through the Electoral College. During the making of the Constitution, states at the North boasted of industrialization and production of ready goods while those in the South primarily relied on agriculture. Union Scribe 1000+ posts Tue Dec-07-10 07:25 PM Response to 32. Instead, they decided to totally scrap the Articles and create a new Constitution, known as "a bundle of compromises. Obama once claimed he wouldn't sign a health care bill without a public option.
But it was and is still just a set of ideas written by flawed men, not a set of stone tablets handed down by some fictional all mighty Captain America Jesus. This branch came about when statesmen who met in Philadelphia were followers of Montesquieu's concept that powers in politics should be balanced. You aren't holding my mortgage. This is not an argument about the wisdom of any specific compromise. Remember, they HAD THE VOTES TO PASS THE PUBLIC OPTION IN RECONCILIATION The statement I made has been backed up. The Virginia Plan had already establishedthat there were three branches of government, but the Connecticut Copromise made the Legislative branch bicameral.