Teacher wars. The teacher wars: a history of America's most embattled profession 2022-10-10
Teacher wars, also known as the education wars or the education reform wars, refer to the ongoing debates and conflicts within the education system about how best to improve the quality of education and address various issues such as underperforming schools, teacher shortages, and funding disparities. These debates often involve different groups with competing interests, such as teachers' unions, school administrators, policymakers, and advocacy groups, and can be highly divisive and polarizing.
One of the main issues at the center of teacher wars is the role and effectiveness of teachers. Some argue that teachers are the most important factor in student achievement, and that investing in teacher development and support is key to improving education outcomes. Others claim that teachers are not solely responsible for student success, and that other factors such as poverty and family background have a greater impact on student achievement.
Another major point of contention in teacher wars is the use of standardized testing as a measure of student and teacher performance. Some believe that standardized tests provide a valuable way to assess student progress and hold teachers accountable, while others argue that they narrow the curriculum and put too much pressure on students and teachers.
Teacher unions and school district administrators are also often at odds in teacher wars, with unions advocating for teacher rights and fair compensation, and school districts looking to control costs and increase accountability. These conflicts can lead to strikes and other forms of protest, disrupting the education process and causing tension between teachers, parents, and school officials.
In recent years, there has been a growing movement to prioritize social and emotional learning in education, which aims to address the emotional and psychological well-being of students and teachers in addition to academic achievement. This movement has faced resistance from some who argue that it is not the role of schools to address these issues, and that such efforts distract from the main goal of education.
Overall, teacher wars are a complex and multifaceted issue that reflects the various competing interests and values in the education system. While there are valid points on both sides of these debates, it is important to find ways to address the various challenges facing education in a fair and effective manner, in order to provide all students with the best possible education.
The Teacher Wars : A History of America's Most Embattled Profession by Dana Goldstein (2015, Trade Paperback) for sale online
Moral panics about teachers over issues ranging from feminization to radicalism to ineffectiveness have been a perennial feature of American political culture since the early nineteenth century. Yet Goldstein argues that certain other movements have born useful fruit: she runs through some data concerning Teach for America and speaks highly of their "transformative" approach though she does not believe, accurately, it can be replicated on a larger scale. It posited a different view of how virtue was formed entirely. Mann was in the unenviable position of wanting to create an extremely costly, tax-payer funded venture in a young, self-made nation that just won a bloody war over the issue of taxes. A lot of good background on some of the ailments our education system is dealing with today. The notion of education as indoctrination has always been somewhat troubling to me, being more of a 'teach them how to think' than a 'what to think' kind of guy.
The teacher wars: a history of America's most embattled profession
Both have strains of strong anti-intellectualism, both have been powered by an appeal to feminine exceptionalism in virtue and emotion, and both adherents are deeply evangelical. While tenure reform is likely a reactionary code word for union busting and liberal media are marginally more pro-teacher, all of the media's attention, discussion and analysis obscure one crucial fact: most teachers are passionate, dedicated, On a daily basis I read articles about state standards, standardized testing, poor teacher training programs and, of course, tenure as culprits behind the declining value of education in the US, which itself may be more hyperbole than legitimate diagnosis. Well worth reading if you are concerned at all about our education system and the current policies for reform. She clearly sees education as crucial to how a country defines itself. But, do we ever really learn from history? From the genteel founding of the common schools movement in the nineteenth century to the violent inner-city teacher strikes of the 1960s and '70s, from the dispatching of Northeastern women to frontier schoolhouses to the founding of Teach for America on the Princeton University campus in 1989, Goldstein shows that the same issues have continued to bedevil us: Who should teach? As I work my way through the book, chapter by chapter, I hope to summarize each battle as Goldstein presents it and reflect on the enduring ramifications for American public education in America today. Or a full-staff would be required to do the auditing and then reporting on teacher performance.
The teacher wars : a history of America's most embattled profession : Goldstein, Dana : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive
As she mentions investing and training a new teacher only to have them leave after a few years is not good investment. Be real about the limitations of our system. But we are given a good presentation of the constantly changing issues of the teaching profession. What will you teach? In her groundbreaking history of 175 years of American education, Dana Goldstein finds answers in the past to the controversies that plague our public schools today. The main questions this chapter left me with include: What might American public education have been if it had initially embraced the classical model? One, I suspect, taxpayers would be happy to pay as I write this, the nation is gearing up for another military adventure in Iraq, and I don't hear the budget hawks screaming yet , particularly if we were to differentiate between the kind of spending we've been doing and the kind of spending we should be doing.
'The Teacher Wars': An Interview With Dana Goldstein (Opinion)
I am not sure if I find that comforting or disheartening. What is the goal of your education system? Midway between absolute autonomy and rigid accountability lies professionalism. At the end of the book, she trots out some not unreasonable suggestions: knock standardized tests back to tools of diagnosis; beef up our oversight of administration Goldstein outlined these ideas in Chicago Tribune piece ; give teachers more active roles in the formation of school curriculum and training; free up time for collaboration. . If that's too brief a nutshell, here's a slightly less-condensed summary: early in the 19th century, reformers like Catharine Beecher "feminized" teaching then more a male profession by hijacking the missionary zeal nascent in urban women: "Go west and make a difference! While tenure reform is likely a reactionary code word for union busting and liberal media are marginally more pro-teacher, all of the media's attention, discussion and analysis obscure one crucial fact: most teachers are passionate, dedicated, and well-trained professionals.
The Teacher Wars: A Review in Two Parts
It is detached from opinion where needs be and offers erudite opinions without dominating. But I'll stand by it. I'm not going to pretend that I don't see these as failed strategies that have caused more harm than good - nor that I don't think that Bill Gates has a lot to answer for in his active promotion of such ideas at the cost of public education in the US. The Teacher Wars upends the conversation about American education by bringing the lessons of history to bear on the dilemmas we confront today. Doubleday: New York, etc. But she is not clear enough in her opposition to their enemies.
The Teacher Wars: A History of America's Most Embattled Profession by Dana Goldstein
I have heard that some find it a little academic, but I found that the author made it very approachable. Goldstein argues that new teachers may not know practical strategies for effective teaching. She implies some of the solutions offered by education reformers should be embraced, even though such solutions are often worse than the problems themselves. The problem with the book is that there are many stories, but not enough analysis. Feldman This is a very dense book on the history of public education in the US lots of names, lots of examples, lots of anecdotes! Through this history, Goldstein asks an uncomfortable question "Could unionized teachers simultaneously fight for their own interests as workers and for the educational interests of the city's children? My hope is that this level of engagement with her work will better help me ingrain the history and key themes of American education and perhaps be helpful to you as well. This article first appeared on EducationNC and is republished here under a Creative Commons license. .
The Teacher Wars
Unions became involved with teachers in the early twentieth century. I experienced it as a child; I worked with it as an adult. She connects the practice, funding, and politics of education to the political and social climate of each decade. Anthony and Elizabeth Cady Stanton had opinions about female educators that continue to be issues today. Therefore, they would train young motivated graduates to teach better.
A Gentler Church: “The Teacher Wars” Reflection
Return tests to their rightful role as diagnostic tools. There are many footnotes but they do not intrude upon the text and there is an excellent bibliography provided. This work is licensed under a Republish our content EdNC is a nonprofit, online, daily, independent newspaper. I don't like thinking of teaching in war-like terms, but there do seem to have key battles right word? A Review by R L Widmann This book is the type that you want to inhale as fast as possible, throw across the room at the wall in furious rage, or read slowly, slowly, page by page. He didn't seem to have any problem with giving the largest handover in history to Wall Street after it nearly brought the world economy to its knees. . Create communities of practice.