Why is corporal punishment wrong. Why Is Corporal Punishment Wrong 2022-10-15
Why is corporal punishment wrong Rating:
Corporal punishment, also known as physical punishment or physical discipline, refers to the use of physical force with the intention of causing pain, discomfort, or bodily injury as a means of discipline or punishment. It can take many forms, including spanking, paddling, or caning, and is often inflicted by parents or guardians on children as a way to correct or discipline their behavior. However, there is a growing consensus among experts and research that corporal punishment is wrong and should be banned.
One of the main reasons why corporal punishment is wrong is that it is ineffective as a means of discipline. Studies have consistently shown that physical punishment does not effectively change behavior in the long term and can even have negative consequences. Children who are physically punished may become more aggressive and rebellious, and may be more likely to exhibit aggressive behavior in the future. Physical punishment can also lead to feelings of anger, shame, and fear in children, which can damage the parent-child relationship and undermine their sense of trust and security.
Another reason why corporal punishment is wrong is that it can have serious physical and emotional consequences for children. Physical punishment can result in bruises, cuts, and other injuries, and can also lead to more serious long-term physical health problems. Research has also shown that corporal punishment is associated with an increased risk of mental health issues, such as depression, anxiety, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). These negative consequences can have a lasting impact on children's well-being and can even affect their future success and relationships.
In addition to the negative effects on children, corporal punishment is also wrong because it is a form of violence and can contribute to a culture of violence in society. Physical punishment sends the message that it is acceptable to use force to solve problems and resolve conflicts, which can lead to a cycle of violence and abuse. It can also normalize violence and aggression, making it more likely that children will engage in these behaviors themselves.
There are more effective and positive ways to discipline and guide children's behavior that do not involve physical punishment. These methods include positive reinforcement, setting clear boundaries and expectations, and using logical consequences. By using these approaches, parents and caregivers can help children learn self-control, self-regulation, and appropriate behavior in a way that is respectful and promotes their well-being.
In conclusion, corporal punishment is wrong because it is ineffective, can have serious physical and emotional consequences for children, and contributes to a culture of violence. There are more positive and effective ways to discipline and guide children's behavior that do not involve physical punishment. It is important for parents and caregivers to understand and use these approaches to help children grow and develop in a healthy and positive way.
Corporal Punishment Is Wrong
When analyzing this topic it is found to have key issues and controversies surrounding whether corporal punishment have negative or positive effects on children when they are exposed to it, there are also multiple perspectives to be looked at about using corporal punishment when it comes to disciplining children. The Case Against Spanking Spanking your child as a form of punishment is very questionable nowadays, a lot of people think it is ok to spank your child and others disagree. Occasionally, when people hear the word punishment, they think of harmful things, which is not always the case. Rupturing these boundaries surfaces the question, "Just exactly WHY are we administering the corporal punishment to students, to hurt them? The risk of being physically punished is similar for boys and girls, and for children from wealthy and poor households. The definition of corporal punishment is, a physical punishment , as flogging, inflicted on the body of one convicted of a crime Dictionary. You are upset at the child. These pros and cons of corporal punishment are not intended to serve as a moral guideline for those who preferred to use it or for those who avoid it.
The problem child is at a major disadvantage; the problem child may be punished for seemingly nothing. The resolution also directs APA to support funding for research in the United States and other countries related to why parents turn to physical discipline. It is defined as a physical punishment which involves hitting someone. The use of corporal punishment instills a level of respect in kids who struggle to interact with authority figures. Infants should never receive a physical consequence because they do not have the capability to understand the difference between a right or wrong decision.
Out of the other 13 that were spanked occasionally as a child do not have or have had any violent charges against them nor do they have mental health issues. Children with disabilities are more likely to be physically punished than those without disabilities. The main advantage to corporal punishment is that it is quick and relatively inexpensive to administer. Although some school districts do not offer guidance to their teachers or administrators regarding the application of corporal punishment, most have rules which must be followed when this disciplinary action is implemented. Children who have been physically punished tend to exhibit high hormonal reactivity to stress, overloaded biological systems, including the nervous, cardiovascular and nutritional systems, and changes in brain structure and function. In most states, corporal punishment only crosses the line into child abuse if it poses a serious risk of physical or psychological harm. Most parents do not want to take the time to reason and explain situations to their children so it is easier to fall back on corporal punishment.
The Pro-Corporal Punishment Is it right, or justifiable, to spank a child? One of the most common times in which parents resort to corporal punishment is when their children have engaged in aggression, such as hitting another child, or antisocial behavior, such as lying or stealing. For instance, spanky children without abusing them have been frowned upon as inhumane. For this reason, corporal punishment has not been outlawed as it has in as many as 34 other countries Jones. Plus, how can you have any moral standing for hitting your child if they have been aggressive towards someone else? After you pay and log-in, the "Download Full Paper" link will instantly download any paper s that you wish! Most of the disadvantages that come with the use of corporal punishment are directly associated with its use when a parent or teacher are frustrated in the heat of the moment. Corporal punishment is socially accepted and widely practiced. I think there needs to be more thorough studies and longer-term studies about using corporal punishment on children to include frequency, the influence of parenting behavior, and other lifestyle factors that can lead to aggressive behavior in kids and other negative behaviors before it can be determined that it is not effective at all. When interviewed about their behaviors, the members of the church said that they whipped the kids because it was a punishment for their incorrect choices.
T he earlier such interventions occur in children's lives, the greater the benefits to the child e. These are the children who typically respond in severe circumstances to a physical consequence that is appropriate for the behaviors they have chosen. Child abuse is defined as the physical or mental injury, sexual abuse or exploitation, negligent treatment, or maltreatment of a child under the age of eighteen. The problem is with corporal punishment if it should be allowed or banned. Straus reported in a 2002 study that about 67% of parents used spanking as a means of corporal punishment Walsh. Studies have shown that lifetime prevalence of school corporal punishment was above 70% in Africa and Central America, past-year prevalence was above 60% in the WHO Regions of Eastern Mediterranean and South-East Asia, and past-week prevalence was above 40% in Africa and South-East Asia.
However punishment is to correct a behavior it is not meant to be solely convenient. It is a concern that has plagued educators for some time because there are many different beliefs about it… Pages: 25 8923 words · Type: Term Paper · Style: APA· Bibliography Sources: 10 Term Paper … Teacher Intervention in School How to motivate and when to intervene with students is among the many challenges that teachers face when handling young students. It creates an environment of fear for the child. Corporal punishment is an inappropriate way to correct bad behavior. Rodriguez advises parents to think strategically and plan ahead. The APA resolution presents effective alternatives that draw broadly on respectful communication, collaborative conflict resolution and parental modeling.
It would seem that corporal punishment has become a form of lazy parenting that allows Americans to avoid the more challenging work of using systematic verbal rewards and punishments in order to encourage positive and pro-social behaviors in their children. Corporal Punishment as a Means of Discipline for Children This paper focuses on the views of corporal punishment as it relates to the discipline of children and why the topic is so controversial. But,… Spanking Verses Child Abuse By defining the vocabulary associated with spanking and child abuse, you effectively show the important contrasts in the two terms. The circumstances around the consequence create a lasting memory which sticks with them for months or years afterward. The organization is also aimed at raising awareness for the removal of corporal punishments and replacing it with non-violent discipline strategies.
Many people believe if their child does something wrong it's okay to spank them however many people, such as myself, feel strongly that it is wrong. The risks of resorting to this consequence in a moment of anger are what limit its overall effectiveness. The paper will state various definitions of corporal punishment as well as a brief history of punishing children with physical force. The only way to stop this cycle is to pass laws to ban the practice in order to stop children from being hurt at home and at school everyday. Her scholarship and teaching focus on child law, child welfare, comparative and international family law, adoption, and constitutional law. Even though 94% of parents with children under four years of age report that they have spent their child at least once with in the past year, and another 76% of men say that a child sometimes needs to be spanked, corporal punishment in schools remains a controversial subject.
They say a child will stop doing this action because they associate it with the punishment. APA also offers the ACT Raising Safe Kids Program to teach positive parenting skills. This leaves teachers to feel like they can do whatever they feel when it comes to punishment. This widespread used corporal punishment has caused there to be mental and physical harm of children caused by over-aggressive and overzealous parents and teachers. In time, hopefully the negative reinforcement will stop the bad behavior. Well I think if all else fails that you should be able to discipline your children with a spanking and not having a huge consequence from the government who was not there by the way, as long as you are not putting your child in the hospital.
Spanking is a necessary evil that helps correct incorrect behavior. Such laws ensure children are equally protected under the law on assault as adults and serve an educational rather than punitive function, aiming to increase awareness, shift attitudes towards non-violent childrearing and clarify the responsibilities of parents in their caregiving role. List of the Cons of Corporal Punishment 1. Corporal punishment is a kind of violence which is done by most of teacher or parents which is purposed to make students discipline or reforming a wrongdoer, or to deter attitudes or behavior deemed unacceptable. The more they corporally punish their children the worse they do in school.