Compare and contrast fairy tale versions. Compare and contrast any two versions of a fairytale of your choice Essay Example 2022-10-25

Compare and contrast fairy tale versions Rating: 7,7/10 717 reviews

Fairy tales have been a beloved form of storytelling for centuries, with many different versions and interpretations existing in various cultures around the world. Despite their widespread popularity, however, there are significant differences in the ways that different versions of these tales are told and the themes and messages they convey. In this essay, we will compare and contrast two well-known fairy tales to explore these differences and consider the impact they have on their audiences.

One well-known fairy tale that has undergone significant changes over time is "Cinderella." In its original form, the story of Cinderella was a French folktale that was recorded by Charles Perrault in the late 17th century. In Perrault's version of the story, Cinderella is a downtrodden young woman who is mistreated by her stepmother and stepsisters. Despite her difficult circumstances, she is able to attend a royal ball thanks to the intervention of her fairy godmother, who transforms her rags into a beautiful gown and carriage. At the ball, Cinderella captivates the prince, who searches for her when she leaves at the stroke of midnight. With the help of her fairy godmother, Cinderella is able to escape the prince's grasp and return to her home, leaving behind only her glass slipper as a clue to her identity. Eventually, the prince is able to find Cinderella and marry her, and they live happily ever after.

While Perrault's version of "Cinderella" has remained popular over the years, it has also been subject to numerous retellings and adaptations. One well-known retelling of the story is the 1950 Disney animated film, "Cinderella." In this version, the story is largely the same, but some elements have been altered or removed. For example, the fairy godmother is given more of a prominent role and is depicted as a maternal figure who helps Cinderella overcome her difficulties. Additionally, the prince is given more depth and personality, and his pursuit of Cinderella is depicted as a romantic and chivalrous gesture rather than a desperate search for a lost woman.

Despite these differences, both versions of "Cinderella" convey similar themes and messages. Both stories emphasize the importance of perseverance and the power of kindness and inner beauty. They also portray the triumph of good over evil and the transformative power of love. However, the Disney version of the story is more overtly romantic and sentimental, with a greater focus on the love story between Cinderella and the prince. This version also includes more overt moral lessons, such as the importance of forgiveness and the dangers of vanity.

Another well-known fairy tale that has undergone significant changes over time is "Snow White." Like "Cinderella," "Snow White" is a story that has been told and retold numerous times, with different versions appearing in various cultures around the world. In its original form, "Snow White" was a German fairy tale that was recorded by the Brothers Grimm in the early 19th century. In this version of the story, Snow White is a young princess who is beloved by all who meet her, including the seven dwarves who take her in after she is driven out of her kingdom by her evil stepmother, the queen. Despite the queen's efforts to kill Snow White, the princess is able to survive thanks to the intervention of the dwarves, who protect her and eventually help her reclaim her kingdom.

Like "Cinderella," "Snow White" has been subject to numerous retellings and adaptations over the years. One well-known version of the story is the 1937 Disney animated film, "Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs." In this version of the story, Snow White is depicted as a more active and assertive character, who is able to escape the queen's

Compare and contrast any two versions of a fairytale of your choice Essay Example

compare and contrast fairy tale versions

Disney, alike many other popular storytellers, want these known stories to be friendly, animated, and with an intended audience of children. When she pleads, her evil stepmother gives her a set of horrible tasks to do and even though Cinderella manages to achieve the near impossible task she is still denied the opportunity to go to the ball and the stepmother instead takes her own daughters and leaves the distraught Cinderella behind. Another common theme is sibling adversary. On the whole, fairy tales are constantly changed to adhere to cultural or social beliefs that are deemed important by diverse people in a community. Another universal theme associated with fairytales that lends itself to comparison in these two tales is the ultimate demise that befalls the evil stepsisters at the end of both stories. We use both the t-chart and the Venn Diagram. Gothel is the antagonist in both, imprisoning Rapuzel for her entire life, and in both she actually does a lot of evil things.

Next

Compare and Contrast Lesson on the Fractured Fairy Tales

compare and contrast fairy tale versions

Where can you find information on fairy tales for children from around the world? Ask the students to tell you some similarities they found between the two stories. This specific version of Cinderella gave birth to the Walt Disney version of Cinderella that most Americans know today. The movie follows their journey to the festival of lights, during which, they fall in love. She bases her study on collective symbols assumed to be present in these stories to shed light on the various facets of the anima. In both books a beautiful girl is one of the most important characters in the story.

Next

Compare and contrast fairy tale versions

compare and contrast fairy tale versions

They can be fantastical and contain hidden morals which may be used by adults to warn children of dangers in society "the entire story is usually made to demonstrate a moral point" Bottigheimer. So, Mother Gothel kidnapped Rapunzel and raised her as her own daughter. She does not come across as angelic in the way she refuses the fishmonger, rice broker and oil merchant by pointing out their failings. They do this to fill their minds with good positive thoughts and leave them with something to think about. Similarly in Lin Lan's version there is also a stepsister. Provide one of the books you just read for independent work on the diagram.


Next

Compare and Contrast Fairy Tales

compare and contrast fairy tale versions

When Rapunzel let down her hair the prince climbed it and the two fell in love. The white bird is similar to the fairy godmother in the modern version because they both are out to help Cinderella and protect her with their magic. Although Rumpelstiltskin and the fairy godmother are almost completely opposites, they do in fact share some key similarities. Wilhelm married while Jacob stayed single. On Rapunzel 12th birthday, the sorceress took the child and locked her in a tower with no visible entrance but only one tiny window. In The Little Mermaid, the ending is a lot happier, which is a major them throughout Disney movies.

Next

Comparing Fairy Tales, Old and New

compare and contrast fairy tale versions

Cinderella is a young girl who is forced into being a servant for her family. It is the wicked stepmother's refusal to let the heroine attend these events that is common to both. By incorporating the fun of these fractured fairy tales, students will enjoy identifying and discussing the differences between them and regular fairy tales. Not only do they teach many lessons, but they are also very entertaining. But when he was caught, he agreed to give their unborn child to the fairy if she would spare them, and she agreed. This theme is pertinent in the plot of all fairytales and the tale of Cinderella is no exception.

Next

Fairy Tale Compare and Contrast .docx

compare and contrast fairy tale versions

The Emperor's New Clothes Analysis 1631 Words 7 Pages Always Expect More Fairy tales and parables are more puissant than any other speech or book, because of their impressive impact on people all over the globe. In the story of Rumpelstilskin, a little girl finds herself in a desperate situation, needing to create gold out of straw by the morning for her King. Nor does she seem in any way saintly when she sends her stepmother Pock Face's roasted remains; I feel this is done in revenge for the stepmother killing and devouring her own mother cow earlier in the story. Without being said, their motives are slightly different as the fairy godmother is an extension of Cinderella herself while Rumpelstiltskin is simply just trying to feed on children. The Queen of the kingdom, who was pregnant, had become ill and had the magic flower found and turned into a soup that healed her. Directions Choose the following story to analyze as you read the classic story version and then view the modern day film, comparing and contrasting the two story versions in a multi-paragraph written analysis. She also wants to be the fairest of them all in both Grimms and in the Disney version.

Next

Compare and Contrast Fairy Tale Versions Lesson Plans & Worksheets

compare and contrast fairy tale versions

Of course there is also the fact that the journey never even happened in the original tale a well, but that difference would require me to retell most of the movie. Project the digital version to teach the class how to play. Cinderella is one of the oldest and most popular children's fairytales, it has been incorporated i. It was written by Lewis Carroll in 1865. No one has ever encountered a dragon in their daily lives unless it is a Komodo Dragon at the local zoo. In the Disney film, Gothel is a selfish woman who kidnaps Rapunzel to help keep her young and beautiful with her healing powers.

Next

Grimm's Fairy Tales and Other Versions

compare and contrast fairy tale versions

They both have long hair, live in a tower, and fall in love. The prince gave it a try the next day and when he went up he frighten Rapunzel for being a man. This could be because people in our day and age like happy endings, and Disney is a business, so they want to appeal to what people like. The sorceress then tricked the prince into climbing the tower. Another large difference between these two stories is the themes presented.


Next

Comparing and Contrasting with Fairy Tales

compare and contrast fairy tale versions

Bettelheim says that there is a fine line between a story holding a child's attention and not; the story must be entertaining but by arousing their imaginationā€¦ Fairytales In Little Red Riding Hood Fairytales. ONLINE Hi, Hope you are doing well. The other sisters were selfish and cruel and were jealous of beauty. . The Brothers Grimm attempt to portray that while all the sisters are quite beautiful it is only Cinderella that possesses inner beauty and that her two stepsisters, although beautiful, their hearts are "fowl and black".

Next