In his essay "Against School," John Taylor Gatto presents a compelling critique of the modern education system. Gatto argues that the traditional school model is designed to create obedient, conformist students who are ill-equipped to think critically and function in a complex world.
Gatto begins by pointing out that the idea of compulsory schooling is relatively new in human history. For most of our existence, children learned by doing and participating in their community, rather than being isolated in a classroom. Gatto suggests that the rise of compulsory education was not motivated by a desire to educate children, but rather by a desire to control and mold them into a certain type of citizen.
One of Gatto's main arguments is that the traditional school model is inherently oppressive. He points out that schools are designed to be hierarchical, with teachers at the top and students at the bottom. This power dynamic creates an unhealthy dynamic between teachers and students, with students being expected to obey authority without questioning it.
Gatto also argues that the traditional school model is not effective at teaching students the skills they need to succeed in life. He points out that the focus on standardized testing and rote memorization does not foster creativity or critical thinking. Instead, it encourages students to become passive learners who are more concerned with pleasing their teachers than with actually learning and growing.
Gatto also highlights the negative impact of the traditional school model on children's mental health. He argues that the pressure to conform and succeed in school can lead to anxiety and depression, and that the lack of autonomy and creativity in the classroom can be demoralizing for students.
Overall, Gatto's essay "Against School" presents a powerful critique of the traditional education system. He argues that it is designed to control and conform rather than educate and empower, and that it fails to prepare students for the complex challenges of the real world. Instead of relying on the traditional school model, Gatto suggests that we should look for alternative ways of educating children that foster creativity, critical thinking, and a sense of agency.
An Analysis of the Article Against School by John Gatto
If a student talks in inapropriate time, if a student is usually late, if a student come to class without knowing any homework, this student likely to hate this lesson. The paper will be revised until you are satisfied. Are your grades inconsistent? Even worse women are considered cause of girl child while science tells that it is the other way round. Not all schools provide safe environments for students; The result of this problem is conflicts and disinterest for learning. This is a way to peacefully refuse to go by the current system and simply reject it by getting large groups to not take the tests that schools hand out. Do you have responsibilities that may hinder you from turning in your assignment on time? Another perk is the smaller size of classes, resulting in more one-on-one attention. People conform when they are trying to pick which restaurant to go to, or which movie to see.
Gatto Against School Analysis
Moreover, the scholars become plagued by the records of their tests leading them to be placed within the lowest level of sophistication. Even though education is power, our social class …show more content… It has been utilized as a way to ease oppression, poverty, and war as the frontrunners are very well given the knowledge to steer the nation towards development. Education makes people healthier by arming them with knowledge that they can use in their daily lives to protect themselves with, so that they can know how to clean and take care of themselves better. It is only then that you can avail your rights as a citizen and seek improvement in the structural functioning of governance and economy. Similar old style dogmas exists everywhere in the world and the only way to eradicate them is proper education. Tone is very complex and can sometimes be difficult to identify. Society begs for better students, better citizens; yet, we mourn for the uneducated generations who are getting pushed more and more to ¨just hurry up and choose¨ instead of waiting to see what these… Argumentative Essay: The Use Of Standardized Testing In Schools Almost every American in the working class, or middle class, thinks that we, as todays students, will not be bale to reach the American dream because of the society we live in.
Against School Gatto Analysis
The government has become routine enough to allow the few students they believe are capable to continue on their tradition, thus allowing the majority of students fall into useless stereotypes and groups. The college system ought to target students like Andrea to supply to message support to assist them address their personal issues. They have been drawn from across all disciplines, and orders are assigned to those writers believed to be the best in the field. Unfortunately, there are many people against mandatory public education in America. He believes that students should explore what they enjoy including: art, philosophy, history, math, and literature. Nevertheless, it does give a number of them a different angle and talks about a number of ways in which education enable social inequality Ballantine. The victims focus more on the next time they might get bullying than on the instructions given by the teacher, so they miss the lesson.
Critical Analysis Of John Taylor Gatto's Essay Against School: [Essay Example], 1371 words GradesFixer
In his article, he goes out of his way to show how bad public schools are, but only uses his personal experience instead of actual facts to back up his points. Government and Education policymakers should be acutely aware of the plight of a student coming from a lower class or lower middle class family. Once the person Thomas Edison began to head to college, he was kicked out as a result of his teacher thought of him tough to manage. My parents always instilled in me an appreciation for diversity and, as research shows, they were correct. Spencer takes an aggressive approach with Holden whereas Mr. This ideology has an astound effect when used as controlling propaganda. The adjustive or adaptive function We all go to school to learn how to react a certain way to authority and do exactly what we are told.
The Rhetorical Analysis Of John Gatto's Against School
I must confess that it almost seems natural to me as a proud product of public education. They are able to handle business papers of any subject, length, deadline, and difficulty! Of course, almost anyone who has gone to school would obviously agree with that statement; boredom is the common condition to everyone who spends time in school. Given this points, lecturers would have the benefits of teaching a category is concentrated on the fabric rather than having to manage students who are uninterested and rude. It was a stable environment that she depended on. He proves this to the reader through his experiences as a teacher and through the students he has taught. He uses several rhetorical strategies in trying to prove his point. When he went to school he was taught through classical schooling, which trained him to develop independent thinking and the appreciation for great old books before his time.
Rhetorical Analysis Of Against Schools By John Gatto
It makes our life really prosperous and meaningful. Against School John Taylor Gatto Summary 358 Words 2 Pages What is school really trying to do with our lives? Gatto was a teacher in Manhattan where he taught for thirty years. The teachers were bored as well, who blamed the students but they were trapped in the same strict structures of the compulsory school program as the students. Gatto's opinion is that they both were products of America's school systems. Although the negatives outweigh the positives there is some positives of conformity. All your information, such as your names, phone number, email, order information, and so on, are protected. Baxter shows this through how the narrator Tommy views his new substitute, Miss Ferenczi.
