A qualitative article critique is a critical evaluation of a qualitative research study. It involves examining the research question, study design, data collection and analysis, and conclusions drawn by the researchers. In order to effectively critique a qualitative article, it is important to have a solid understanding of qualitative research methods and the specific research tradition within which the study is situated.
When evaluating the research question of a qualitative article, it is important to consider whether the question is clear, relevant, and appropriate for a qualitative study. The question should be grounded in the existing literature and should address a gap in knowledge or understanding. It should also be feasible to answer using qualitative methods.
The study design of a qualitative research study should be well-planned and appropriate for the research question. This includes the choice of research setting, participants, and data collection methods. It is important to consider whether the design allows the researchers to explore the research question in depth and to generate rich, nuanced data.
Data collection is a critical aspect of qualitative research, as it determines the type and quality of data that is collected. It is important to consider the appropriateness of the data collection methods used in the study, as well as the rigor with which they were implemented. For example, were multiple data sources used, such as interviews, observations, and documents? Were the data collected in a systematic and transparent manner?
Data analysis is also a key component of a qualitative research study. It is important to consider the techniques used to analyze the data, as well as the rigor with which they were applied. Were the data analyzed in a systematic and transparent manner, using appropriate coding and categorization techniques? Were the findings supported by the data and were the conclusions drawn by the researchers supported by the data?
In conclusion, a qualitative article critique involves a critical evaluation of the research question, study design, data collection and analysis, and conclusions drawn by the researchers. It is important to consider the rigor and appropriateness of these aspects of the study in order to determine the validity and reliability of the findings. By conducting a thorough critique of a qualitative research study, researchers can gain a deeper understanding of the study and its implications for future research.
Qualitative Article Critique Example Nursing Essay
In the discussion section, we consider how well the author of the qualitative article articulates the answers to the research question and how the findings are placed in the context of the reviewed literature. We have proactive customer support agents to ensure clients' issues are addressed and orders delivered in a timely manner. The teacher is also described as being 31 years old, African American, and having 10 years experience. In this particular study, some uncontrolled variables such as the presence of other illnesses apart from those under study may present a threat to the internal validity. Overall, the literature review is written from an interpretive definitive voice e.
The conclusion provides a simple yet concise summary of the study and its findings for future consideration Naga et. MethodProtection of Participant Rights The researchers held four focus two in English, two in Spanish groups consisting of oral interview questions to conduct their research. The researchers did not provide a detailed description of those strategies, but after re-scanning the article, it was evident that strategies were used. The final sample size was eight subjects who were chosen after having been interviewed by the researcher. The design is appropriate since it will provide insights into how the nursing practice can be strengthened to provide care for patients with depression and heart disease or diabetes. .
Study Variables Independent variables, according to StatSoft n. This model is relevant because it supports the different concepts associated with cancer pain management and the needs of patients Naga et. The researchers were wondering how people define the word stress due to past researches participants used to define the word stress with different meanings. Then the participants gave verbal consent to participate in the study. Some practical guidelines for effective sample-size determination. The transferability element describes the extent to which the findings of qualitative research can be transferred to other contexts or settings with other participants. In education, patients need to have continued education on how they can manage the stressors that leads to depression as well as their lifestyle habits.
Qualitative article critique, Sample of Research papers
Both papers address a similar topic chronic pain , which makes it easy to compare and contrast how the researchers present their findings and other critical aspects. Thus, the study compares and contrasts how a quantitative paper by Hadi et al. This suggests that perspective on flourishing for Indigenous contenders could differentiate from non-Indigenous contenders. Research Method s The researchers deploy a mixed-methods design but the paper hardly provides any information regarding the initiatives that were implemented to combat any threats or harm to the participants. She used an external auditors, i. The criteria for determining the trustworthiness of qualitative research are discussed below.
The phenomenon is the impact of the presence of a family while a patient is undergoing an intensive medical procedure. . Findings presented in qualitative research papers can be enriched by including quotes or other similar data to enhance confirmability. Therefore, the potential risk is the possibility of misunderstanding or failure to present the accurate perceptions and opinion of participants about the research subject. This study is therefore informed by the need to come up with a new practice model that can facilitate the diagnosis of depression among patients suffering from diabetes and heart disease Morgan et al, 2009.
Qualitative Article Critique Example [wl1p7qe0g5lj]
Although her study was limited in sample size and one-time interview, her preliminary findings are consistent with the related literature and buttress the use of acupuncture as a treatment to substance abuse. The abstract also describes a summary of the information gathered from the interviews and the necessity to increase pain management knowledge from a nursing-based perspective Rustoen et. As more and more patients began exhibiting these symptoms, hospitals started to see an influx of patients. For example, a longitudinal perspective could produce more solid evidences on the effectiveness of acupuncture as a treatment to substance abuse, although this was properly acknowledged by the researcher at the end of the report. What literature gap is this research hoping to fill 1 : The literature gap in the research is that Multi-layered examinations exhibit that impression of flourishing are affected by specific social norms and change across social orders. Carefully considering these factors when critiquing qualitative research articles can be helpful in determining the quality and importance of the findings. Information of ethnic minority men, white women and white men was also collected as comparability.
Literature Review A review of the literature was undertaken in the study, which met the philosophical underpinnings of the study and summarized the existing body of knowledge related to the research problem. However, after going through that section, one cannot really point to a clearly stated Statement of the problem. Age also contributed to the way students react to the ethnographer along with what he or she is and is not allowed to do Hammersley and Atkinson, 1983. Hence, this research subject should be of high interest to the organization. Findings The findings were effectively summarized, with good use of excerpts and supporting arguments. I faded into the background.
Quantitative & Qualitative Article Research Critique
Interviews are particularly useful for getting the story behind a. Therefore, it is important to identify different factors from a nursing-based perspective that will ultimately support patient outcomes and effectiveness in a manner that is consistent with improved patient outcomes Naga et. The researchers provide the reader with many details that ultimately convince the reader that there is sufficient evidence to demonstrate that a problem exists and further research is needed. The concept of cancer survivorship was extensively defined, among other things. The accurate replication is very difficult to achieve because an event in natural setting cannot be reproduced. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 71 2 , 381-390.