Comparing cinderella stories. Comparing Cinderella Stories 2022-10-06

Comparing cinderella stories Rating: 6,2/10 1585 reviews

Cinderella stories, also known as rags-to-riches tales, are a popular theme in literature and folklore around the world. These stories revolve around a young protagonist who overcomes adversity and rises to a higher social status through their wit, bravery, or the help of a magical being. Cinderella stories have been told for centuries and have been adapted in various cultures, resulting in a diverse range of interpretations of this classic tale.

One of the most well-known versions of the Cinderella story is the European fairytale of Cinderella, in which a young girl named Cinderella is mistreated by her stepmother and stepsisters and is ultimately rescued from her miserable life by a prince. This version of the story has been adapted numerous times in literature, film, and other media, and has become a cultural icon.

Another popular version of the Cinderella story is the Chinese story of Ye Xian, also known as The Golden Lotus. In this version, Ye Xian is a young girl who is mistreated by her stepmother and stepsisters and is ultimately rescued by a fish who helps her to attend a festival and win the heart of the prince. This version of the story emphasizes the importance of kindness and compassion, as Ye Xian is able to triumph over her adversities through her good nature.

In the Korean version of the Cinderella story, titled "The Story of Chunhyang," the protagonist, Chunhyang, is a young girl who is sold into marriage to the governor of a province. Despite the challenges she faces, Chunhyang remains loyal to her husband and ultimately triumphs over her adversities. This version of the story emphasizes the importance of loyalty and perseverance.

One notable difference between these versions of the Cinderella story is the role of the magical being or "fairy godmother" character. In the European version of Cinderella, a fairy godmother helps Cinderella attend the ball and win the prince's heart. In the Chinese version of the story, a fish helps Ye Xian attend the festival and win the prince's heart. In the Korean version of the story, Chunhyang does not receive any help from a magical being and instead relies on her own wit and strength to overcome her adversities.

Despite these differences, all of these Cinderella stories share a common theme of the protagonist rising from humble beginnings to a higher social status through their own actions or the help of a magical being. These stories serve as a source of inspiration and hope for readers, reminding us that even in the face of adversity, it is possible to overcome obstacles and achieve success.

Cinderella Story Comparisons

comparing cinderella stories

Or you can simply print out the work sheet and let students use pencils or pens to complete it. The violent version of Cinderella by the Grimm Brother explains the struggle she faced trying to get away from her stepsisters but also keeping her humble and kind side looking for true love. There are many varieties of beans, some with New World origins and others with their origins in the Old World. Teaching Compare and Contrast Strategies with Different Cinderella Stories My colleagues and I have been working a lot this year on comparing and contrasting texts on a similar topic with the upper grade students at my school. However, her destiny was changed when she married with the Cinderella Research Paper 708 Words 3 Pages Cinderella was the princess of Sparta, and she was a loving and caring queen and all her subjects loved her.

Next

Comparing Cinderella Stories

comparing cinderella stories

It is thought that the original Cinderella story is the Chinese version entitled Yeh Shen. AttitudeBehaviorCharacterCommunication SkillsGroup WorkInterests and TalentsParticipationSocial SkillsTime ManagementWork Habits Attitude The student: is an enthusiastic learner who seems to enjoy school. Comparing Cinderella Stories Around the World Soon, they were ready to talk about geography. Ruth Heller is a wonderful illustrator. Another similarity between the stories they both danced with the prince.

Next

Comparing Cinderella Stories for Kids

comparing cinderella stories

Compare Cinderella stories in your classroom! Ever After, a 1998 American romantic comedy movie, is based on France during the Renaissance time. Ask students to look for things that the story of Cinderella has in common with The Rough-Face Girl. But for those who are self-seeking and who reject the truth and follow evil, there will be wrath and anger. Objectives Students will learn about changes that occurred in the New World and Old World as a result of early exploration. Compare and Contrast Lesson Plan Today I'm sharing my 4-day compare and contrast lesson plan using different Cinderella stories from around the world CCSS 3.

Next

Comparing and Contrasting Cinderella Stories

comparing cinderella stories

With my free printables, teachers will have everything they need to help students compare and contrast reading passages, characters, story elements and more! Practicing this at home would be helpful. This fairytale reflects values such as perseverance and determination. For example: Many sources note that tomatoes originated in the New World; The Food Timeline indicates that tomatoes were introduced to the New World in 1781. I believe Walt Disney changed the story from the three-day festival to the one-night ball because the children watching would ultimately get tired of the same story of Cinderella dancing with the prince three nights in a row. All of these 900+ stories are popular including the Norwegian version Katie Woodencloak and the French version Cinderella. Write black hair in the circle devoted to The Rough-Face Girl and write yellow hair in the circle devoted to Cinderella. But, there Fairy Tales By The Brother 's Grimm, Rapunzel And Cinderella numerous times, varying with a changing society.

Next

Compare And Contrast Two Versions Of A Cinderella Story

comparing cinderella stories

Write mean sisters in the area where the two circles intersect. It is such a popular story that nearly every culture has a version of her with different traits. She is forced to do housework and is not allowed to take part fun activities or share luxuries with her stepsisters. You might adapt the lesson by sharing some of the food items in the Food Lists section below. Their eyes are pecked out by pigeons and become blind.

Next

Comparing Cinderella Interpretations

comparing cinderella stories

She sings to keeps herself happy during her enslavement which, along with some help from the falcon god Horus, ultimately delivers her from her predicament. List the similarities and differences on this diagram. It was time for a visit to the library. Sneed read Yeh Shen aloud. Over the next few days, Ms. But over the years, various parent groups, scholars and film critics have accused Disney for creating shallow, stereotypical princesses whose ultimate aim was to find her 'prince charming ' and live happily ever after. Practicing these at home would be very helpful.

Next

Comparing Themes In Cinderella Stories

comparing cinderella stories

At the same time, one may encounter different interpretations of the Cinderella, given that the Disney Cinderella was first filmed in the 1950s. On the contrary, the movie did not have such objective, and the directors wished to provide a new look into the well-known story. Sneed opened her laptop again and began to search. Slowing down and taking more time would help with this. This is similar to France Cinderella when her godmother gave her a beautiful dress for the ball. Shirley climo has ventured to many places learning about different culture and writing classic tales through the story lenses of different cultures. Sneed pulled out Answers ranged from the U.

Next

Compare And Contrast The Three Versions Of Cinderella

comparing cinderella stories

Cinderella Stories Compare and Contrast Lesson Plan now! The Little Golden book, the Grimm brothers version and the 2015 Disney Film version of Cinderella are all taken from the original story. . Over the years, numerous versions of the story have been recreated and have been told to children all over the world. Cinderella wished for nothing but to leave the horribly people more than ever. She was loved endlessly by all creatures, big and small. I think my favorite would be the Chinese version Yeh — Shen.

Next

Cinderella Stories Compare and Contrast Lesson Plan, Grades 3

comparing cinderella stories

The ability to compare and contrast is an important reading strategy for students to learn. They have different magic, Yeh - Shen has a fish, Aschenputtel has a tree, and The Algonquin Cinderella has an Comparing Mary Santiago And Another Cinderella Story Once Upon A Song to make her out of their servant. Notice that some items appear on both lists -- beans, for example. Interests and Talents The student: has a well-developed sense of humor. Cinderella gets married to the prince, however, the step-sisters are forgiven and live with Cinderella at the castle unlike the original story.

Next

Comparing Cinderella and The Rough

comparing cinderella stories

Have them place an asterisk or checkmark next to the food item each time they find that item in a different source. Group Work The student: offers constructive suggestions to peers to enhance their work. The year when all this took place was 400 B. Cinderella, the protagonist, is an outcast her family, as her father is her only blood relative. Campbell continued down the shelf pulling out books. She went in a pumpkin and her godmother made it into a carriage. Our understanding of what it means to be a Disney princess is probably one of the reasons to what made us subject to the regulation of cultural values.

Next