Socrates antigone. Antigone vs. Socrates Essay on 2022-10-04

Socrates antigone Rating: 8,8/10 604 reviews

Socrates and Antigone are two significant figures in ancient Greek philosophy and literature who have made lasting impacts on the way we think and reflect upon ethical and moral issues. Despite living in different time periods and coming from different cultural backgrounds, both Socrates and Antigone grappled with similar themes of justice, obedience, and the role of the individual in society.

Socrates, a philosopher who lived in ancient Athens during the 5th century BC, is best known for his method of questioning, known as the Socratic method, which he used to challenge the beliefs and assumptions of his fellow Athenians. Through his questioning, Socrates sought to uncover the truth about a variety of topics, including the nature of virtue, the role of the state in society, and the importance of knowledge and wisdom.

One of the key themes that emerges in Socrates' philosophy is the idea of justice. According to Socrates, justice is not simply about following the laws of the state, but rather about doing what is right and fair, regardless of whether or not it is in accordance with the laws of the state. This is exemplified in the story of Socrates' trial and execution, in which he willingly accepted the death penalty rather than renounce his beliefs and principles. In doing so, Socrates demonstrated his commitment to the pursuit of truth and justice, even in the face of great personal cost.

Like Socrates, Antigone, the protagonist of the play by Sophocles of the same name, also grappled with the idea of justice. In the play, Antigone defies the laws of the state by burying her brother, Polynices, who was considered a traitor by the ruling authorities. In doing so, Antigone is acting in accordance with her own sense of justice and moral obligation, even though it means going against the laws of the state.

One of the key themes that emerges in Antigone's story is the idea of obedience. Antigone must decide whether to obey the laws of the state or follow her own sense of right and wrong. Ultimately, she chooses to follow her own conscience and pay the price for her actions. In doing so, Antigone demonstrates the importance of personal responsibility and the ability of individuals to make their own decisions, even in the face of external pressure.

Both Socrates and Antigone illustrate the importance of standing up for what one believes in and acting in accordance with one's own sense of justice and moral obligation. Through their actions and words, they challenge the status quo and encourage others to think critically and make decisions based on their own beliefs and values. In this way, Socrates and Antigone have had a lasting impact on the way we think about ethics and morality, and continue to inspire us to stand up for what we believe in and strive for a more just and equitable world.

Socrates and Antigone: Philosophical Comparison

socrates antigone

On the other hand, if you truly believe that a law is unjust, then you should follow your convictions until the law is changed or becomes acceptable. . Politicians today often do not: studies have found over 30 different ways that certain politicians have failed to respond to questions in political interviews. Without this, he claimed, life was not worth living How so? True enough — he claims no knowledge, charges no tuition, connects himself to no particular school. Here are some examples: Symposium, 175E , Exodus 22:1.


Next

What Sort of Thing is a Socrates?

socrates antigone

Plato himself compels his reader to practise starting over again, empty-handed. Chad Bochan Start reading about the Athenian philosopher Socrates c. Antigone used these tactics differently from Dr. In accepting his punishment, he is able to prove the depth of his convictions and continue to stand for those ideals he has stood for in the past. Socrates In the plays Antigone and the Crito the two lead characters, Antigone and Socrates, showed completely different ideas regarding their responsibilities to the State. Either interlocutor or any, if there are more than two can at any moment perform the role of agent or patient, that of the healing or the sickly soul.

Next

Antigone vs. Socrates

socrates antigone

What, in short, is X? Socrates must therefore make certain that Gorgias shares his own belief about the value of refutation for the one refuted. Moreover, Antigone and Socrates relied on the belief that what they were doing was in accordance with the divine and just. Attention to the form of Socratic discussion shows that how the discussants talk to each other is often as important as what they say to each other. Socrates was so against breaking the law, that even when he thought he was not guilty and in jail for corrupting youthful people and not believing in the gods, he would not escape. Whereas some are convinced that laws should never be broken, others maintain that there are some instances where laws should be broken.

Next

Learning from the Master: Socrates’ Examined Life

socrates antigone

If this rule is followed, then discussants will lay the blame for their confusions on themselves and not on the other party. Words: 5241 - Pages: 21 Premium Essay Philosophy. The statue of John Stuart Mill T. Any law that violates the constitution is unlawful and should be rid of as soon as possible. There is no doubt, however, that the history of political thought is replete with attempts to provide a satisfactory account of political obligation, from the time of Socrates to the present. He is lacking in determination, and his belief is that with power, he can do whatever he want without knowing what's right or….

Next

Plato's Socrates and Sophocle's Antigone

socrates antigone

The phrase is the same: pothou kentron. Perhaps Plato stood out like a grand old man in diminished circumstances, and I recognized him without quite knowing who he was. He knew that the certain kind of wisdom he had was difficult to convince other people. Willingness may be too weak. The word muōps contains the associations of the oistros with longing, madness, and philosophical transcendence, but it also contains the associations of the spur with control and skill. It depends on Simmias and Cebes, on the quality and arrangement of their souls.

Next

(DOC) Socrates and Antigone: two ways not to be martyred

socrates antigone

After being caught in the act, she was taken to the palace and when asked by Creon why she did it. Juno surprises Jupiter and Io, Jan Jansz van Bronkhorst, c. By doing this, she prevents him from having much direct control over her life and thus is still fiercely defending her right to make her own decisions. In contrast, the basic elements of their arguments are different. In both the Symposium and the Phaedrus, one transforms into a lover of wisdom by beginning with the sight of a beautiful body. Socrates has been ordered to philosophize by Apollo, his superior in ethical matters. The divine law says that all man should be buried following the proper rites.

Next

Antigone vs. Socrates in the Crito

socrates antigone

She would also argue that the punishment which Socrates had chosen to settle with was comparatively lesser attractive as compared to the alternative of fleeing …show more content… Therefore, Creon declares that Antigone and her sister be put to death. The two sons of Oedipus, Eteocles and Polynices killed each other. Neither one could bring themselves to beg for mercy when they were sentenced to death, instead opting to restate their case before execution was carried out. . In the soul of the tyrant, the oistros is an affliction.


Next

Antigone vs. Socrates Essay on

socrates antigone

In the Crito, Socrates must choose between obedience of the state and obedience to his family and goodness of the gods. I began to live as though life were not trivial. Therefore, the essay prompts given on the SAT must be fairly open-ended, so that anyone with a highschool education and life experiences common to all teenagers can respond to them. The conflict results in Socrates The Tragedy Of Antigone beard stroking Socrates, and master of the stylish intellectual pose, in his relatively modern book speaks volumes of Greek society. Dozens of refutations lie waiting in the pages of Plato for us to take apart and use ourselves, if we wish to live an examined life as he did. To fall in love with wisdom is to alter the orientation of the soul. But why does Socrates, in the context of the Gorgias, mention this distressing fact? Now, beyond a realisation that the characters in the dialogue do not know what they thought they knew, how does this kind of inquiry improve its participants? The Euthyphro, for example, is set at the steps of the courthouse where Socrates is about to face charges of impiety, when he bumps into Euthyphro, who is about to prosecute his own father for impiety.

Next