William carlos williams the use of force analysis. The Use of Force by William Carlos Williams, 1938 2022-10-02
William carlos williams the use of force analysis Rating:
In his short story "The Use of Force," William Carlos Williams explores the complex relationship between a doctor and his young patient, as well as the ethical dilemmas that can arise in the medical profession. The story begins with the narrator, a doctor, being called to a house to examine a sick child, who is described as being "cross and obstinate." From the beginning, there is a sense of tension between the doctor and the child, as the doctor becomes increasingly frustrated with the child's refusal to open her mouth and allow him to examine her throat.
As the story progresses, the doctor becomes more and more determined to examine the child, and he eventually resorts to using physical force to open her mouth. Despite the child's cries and protests, the doctor persists, ultimately revealing that she has diphtheria, a potentially deadly illness.
One of the key themes of the story is the use of power and authority. The doctor, as an authority figure, is used to being obeyed, and he becomes increasingly frustrated when the child refuses to comply with his requests. The doctor's use of physical force can be seen as a manifestation of his desire to exert control over the situation, and it is clear that he sees the child's refusal to cooperate as a personal affront.
Another important theme is the tension between personal feelings and professional obligations. The doctor is clearly upset by the child's stubbornness, and he becomes emotionally involved in the situation. However, as a medical professional, he is also bound by a code of ethics that requires him to do everything in his power to protect the health and well-being of his patients. The doctor ultimately must choose between his own emotions and his professional duty, and he ultimately decides to prioritize the child's health over his own feelings.
In conclusion, "The Use of Force" is a thought-provoking exploration of the complex dynamics that can arise in the medical profession. Williams effectively portrays the tension between personal feelings and professional obligations, as well as the power dynamics that can exist between doctors and their patients. Through the character of the doctor, Williams raises important questions about the ethical implications of using force in the pursuit of medical treatment.
Analysis of "The Use of Force"
She continues to say no, like many women have to sex, yet the doctor pursues her. When the doctor asks the father to hold Mathilda, the father is so afraid of hurting her that he lets her loose just as the doctor is about to get a good look at her throat. Both these stories also serve to reveal a common threat unifying much of his work in the form of short fiction. Williams spent most of his life working as a pediatrician, and much of his writing draws from that experience. The Use of Force Characters The characters in "The Use of Force" are the doctor, Mathilda Olson, and Mr.
"The Use of Force" by William Carlos Analysis Essay Example
The husband is a physician and in the beginning of her writing she has nothing but good things to say about him, which is very obedient of her. The daughter refused to show her throat to her parents and the doctor. Diphtheria is a very bad disease and it is a disease that can be given to a whole lot of people in the town. The medical profession is one such section of society on which such a duty has been imposed in the strictest sense. She even attacked the doctor after he saw what he needed to see, so there was no chance that she would have ever cooperated with him. Chen, this story talk about how difficult to make a medical decision between doctor and their patients.
Grant was taught this lesson when she came face to face with a unique patient. She scratches him and bites into pieces the tongue depressor he finally forces into her mouth. The dialogue, however, is written without quotation marks, which helps render the subjective point of view of the narrator. Yet the reader is caught up in the dramatic irony of knowing that the physician would indeed hurt her if he had to, for his only aim is to diagnose her illness. Almost every reader could relate to why she felt this particular way. Olson are Mathilda's parents. By this time, the doctor had to use force on the child with the acceptance to use the force from her parents.
Analysis Of “The Use Of Force” By William Carlos Williams Essay Example (600 Words)
From chapter 33, the main question which can be paused surrounding on justification good deeds with purpose. The characters include the doctor, as the protagonist, and Mathilda and her parents, as secondary characters. When medical professional oath to help their patient by doing everything possible. Narrated as a physical struggle between the examining physician and the stubborn young patient, the story is a single episode focused entirely on the battle of wills. The tale describes the visit of a doctor to a family home, and upon his stay, he is met by Mathilda Olson, a young girl determined in making the doctor's task of diagnosing her go uncompleted. The mother and father both have the same intentions for their daughter but I believe that the mother is more sympathetic and the father just wants to get things over with. Why is he calling her a "savage brat"? Shadowing Patients: A Case Study 755 Words 4 Pages After observing and shadowing doctors, there is so much more to being a healer than merely possessing medical knowledge and practicing the medicine.
At this point the doctor lost control of his anger and he became furious. You can help us out by revising, improving and updating thissection. His experience as a physician frequently informed his writing, and it offered him a unique perspective on the relationship between doctor and patient. The Use Of Force By William Carlos Williams And Final Exam By Pauline W. A hero must also be able to take over for others who may feel as though there is no other option but to give up. It is hard to draw a clear line in deciding what the appropriate roles are of both the patient and the medical professional. The doctor possess power over the patient already has.
The Use of Force by William Carlos Williams Analysis
Nuland opens the medical-scientific novel with a fictional story of a young nameless girl who is inching closer to her birth date. However, what if the circumstances required a healthcare professional to use such coercion if it meant saving a life? The last date is today's date — the date you are citing the material. There are some similarities but then again in the story it seems to be more of a myth then reality. The claim that the paternalistic model is the appropriate and most realistic model will be argued in this paper. See eNotes Ad-Free Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts. He was very ashamed of how his daughter was behaving.
Analysis of “the Use of Force” by William Carlos Williams
They both were treated without their consent to the treatment because they are considered too young to make a decision by themselves. It was rough but it might have been rough but it saved the girls life. Born: Rutherford, New Jersey, 17 September 1883. The relationship between a physician and a patient is often seen as a relationship with no errors or ethical concerns but that is not the case. From her friend, she learns there are two obstetric divisions, one run by doctors and the other by midwives, advising the soon to be mom to stay clear of medical students. Latest answer posted February 24, 2012, 1:03 pm UTC 1 educator answer Mr.
Wade Argumentative Essay 1038 Words 5 Pages Before Roe v. Though he initially wants to help Mathilda, his reason and professionalism are quickly overshadowed by his urge to dominate his reluctant patient. In the story the doctor goes over with very professional means but later on gets frustrated with the little girl. There are many children who will accept going to the doctor, and are okay as long as there is no pain during the visit. Grant writes about how she came to contact with a patient she had nicknamed Mr. The Doctors Plague Chapter Summary 1104 Words 5 Pages Judeah Auguste University of Alaska Anchorage The Doctors Plague, Sherwin B.
Other wise she may have faced and untimely death. Factors such as the type of neighborhood, race, and the behavior of the suspect all play a role in the decision making process to use deadly force. The short story titled The Use of Force by William Carlos Williams, a doctor tries to treat a young girl who refuses the treatment he offers. Yes, the doctor had to use force and it was justified because a lot of people could have got infected from what she had. Williams uses a lot of elements in the story to help create meaning to the story.
As he wrote in his Autobiography, "They had no knowledge and no skill at all. But what happens when the person who is supposed to help us, a master of medicine, does not have our best interest at heart? In this story, many issues which are debated are social issues. Nuland Kraft The Doctors Plague depicts the story of the lifeline of Ignac Semmelweis, a physician in the First Division at the Allgemeine Krankenhaus hospital in Vienna and his discovery of childbed fever. Should doctors really hold complete responsibility for our health? He created the music for some of the best movies of all time. Individuals have different coping mechanisms that help with tough situations through life. Because of incompetence, these patients are not able to make decisions for themselves. There is a slight difference in this than what Mitford was explaining, because the family is not overwhelmed with new money, but worried about how they can afford to keep their relative alive on a ventilator or other machines prolonging life.