Should child soldiers be prosecuted for their crimes. Should Child Soldiers Be Prosecuted For Their Crimes Essay 2022-10-31
Should child soldiers be prosecuted for their crimes Rating:
Child soldiers are children under the age of 18 who are recruited by armed groups to participate in armed conflict. They may be used as fighters, cooks, porters, or for other tasks. Many child soldiers are forced to participate in armed conflict against their will and are subjected to physical and psychological abuse. The use of child soldiers is a grave violation of international law and human rights.
The question of whether child soldiers should be prosecuted for their crimes is a complex one. On the one hand, child soldiers are often coerced into participating in armed conflict and may not fully understand the consequences of their actions. They may also be under the influence of drugs or other substances, which can impair their judgment. On the other hand, child soldiers may commit serious crimes during armed conflict, including murder, rape, and other acts of violence.
There are a number of different approaches that have been taken to address the issue of child soldiers. Some argue that child soldiers should be treated as victims of conflict and should not be prosecuted for their crimes. Others argue that child soldiers should be held accountable for their actions, but that their age and circumstances should be taken into account in determining the appropriate punishment.
One approach that has been used in some countries is to provide rehabilitation and reintegration programs for child soldiers. These programs can help child soldiers to overcome the trauma of their experiences and to reintegrate into society. Some countries have also established special courts or tribunals to deal with the crimes of child soldiers. These courts may take into account the age and circumstances of the child soldiers, as well as the severity of their crimes, in determining the appropriate punishment.
Ultimately, the decision of whether to prosecute child soldiers for their crimes should be based on a careful consideration of the individual circumstances of each case. It is important to recognize that child soldiers are often victims of conflict and may have been coerced into participating in armed conflict. At the same time, it is also important to hold child soldiers accountable for their actions and to ensure that justice is served.
Should child soldiers be prosecuted for their crimes?
But the real question is, when will these acts stop? The Arab countries are suffering multiple problems that reflect on their way of dealing with child soldiers. For instance, genocide need next to the general mental element stated in article 30 to a special intent. This is what we are doing. Of course others may say differently. In these situations, prosecuting child soldiers may be needed under the guarantee of a fair trial, and respect the principle of child best interest, and for the purpose of rehabilitation and reintegration Amnesty, 2000.
Children should not be prosecuted. This shows how child soldiers are forced into war whether it is because they are being forced, or because they have nowhere else to go. That day when he was at this school the teachers had brought in 3 scared kids. Prosecution of a child should always be regarded as a measure of last resort and the purpose of any sentence should be to rehabilitate and reintegrate the child into society. When child soldiers become adults Dominic Ongwen was about 10 when he became a soldier with the Lords' Resistance Army in the 1980s. Permitting States to decide their own age of criminal responsibility would allow them to determine the scope of their international obligations. Many of them suffer from drug addiction and are basically brainwashed.
Should Child Soldiers Be Prosecuted For Their Crimes Essay
They refer to their commanders as father Should Child Soldiers Be Granted Amnesty Essay 569 Words 3 Pages As long as former child soldiers show that they will not recommit their acts of violence, they should be granted amnesty. They are forced into fighting. Child soldiers rarely have the same understanding of their decisions and actions as adults and therefore should not be held responsible for their actions. Everywhere they look violence is near and cannot be escaped. Consequently, if the mental element exists the subordinates shall be held responsible for their actions alongside their commander Bigi, 2010.
These children knew exactly what they were doing and should not be excused from their actions simply because they are thought to be too young to take responsibility. Honestly, these kids have also been the ones killing families and recruiting other kids. The age of criminal responsibility varies from country to country, from 7-16, but the bar is most commonly set at 14. Personal research has been conducted and has… Pros And Cons Of Involuntary Child Soldiers Child soldiers should be given amnesty unless they did it voluntarily. And recruiters do not care about what kids are taught.
You think these kids want to do what they did? It is unlikely that prosecutions after the fact would have this effect. There is a debate whether or not children should be prosecuted for their war crimes. Ishmael Beah, a child soldier himself talked in a interview about a lady who worked in the rehabilitation center he was sent to who was always kind to him, which at first angered it but it was healing him without him knowing it. Children and Accountability for International Crimes: the contribution of international criminal courts. One reason is that they commit terrible crimes. Challenges in establishing the accountability of child soldiers for human rights violations: Restorative justice as an option.
These children are often seen as targets because they are under aged and not able to take responsibility for their actions so they are targeted to be able to kill without punishment. Many of the most aggressive and abusive acts of wartime have been committed by child soldiers. Is it people with tanks and Ak-47s fighting each other? TRT World and Agencies Child soldiers around the world, even if they have no agency in the matter, commit war crimes. Kids from the war that are soldiers are not different from kids that have been committed to a crime so why should the kid soldiers not be committed for killing people. Nevertheless, the particularity of child soldiers requires a different approach. Medical treatment is instrumental in getting former child soldiers rehabilitated and reintegrated.
Should Child Soldiers Be Prosecuted For Their Crimes?
Should these children be given amnesty? He was then granted amnesty in The United States of America. They should be allowed amnesty. When all the factors seemingly balance out to me, the outlying factor is the fact that crimes are being comitted. Prosecuting child soldiers is a way of protecting the children. Essay On Should Child Soldiers Be Given Amnesty 1412 Words 6 Pages Have you ever thought about the long-lasting argument over whether child soldiers should be given amnesty? They are victims, they believe what they are doing the right thing. Prosecution of a child should always be regarded as a measure of last resort and the purpose of any sentence should be to rehabilitate and reintegrate the child into society. Next, not prosecuting child soldiers would encourage commanders to use them more.
Analysis: Should child soldiers be prosecuted for their crimes?
People may say that they could sacrifice their own lives instead of killing others, but that is too much to expect of kids. Child soldiers should therefore not be held responsible for actions they were forced to commit and had little understanding of. We also need to consider the fact that there are children who do volunteer to join the army. Picture this, your family is killed by terrorists and you have nowhere else to go. Most countries like Syria, Iraq, Sudan, and Yemen do not have any Disarmament, Demobilization, and Reintegration programs Al-Maliki, 2020; Al-Zain, 2020; Al-Adrawe, 2020. The Lubanga case Tomaso Falchetta, Child Soldiers International CSI legal and policy adviser, told IRIN child soldiers should be viewed as victims and the NGO opposed their prosecution, as emphasis should be on the criminal responsibility of the adult recruiters. This is what most of the child soldiers are doing.
“Analysis: Should child soldiers be prosecuted for their crimes?,” IRIN News, 6 Oct. 2011
However, there are, of course, outliers — deviants from the standard norm; these outliers make one wonder what the norm truly is, why it is so Brief Summary Of Arrangement Of Book the center permanently and says goodbye to Esther. Finally the comparison between a child soldier in a country such as, Sierra Leone or Northern Uganda to that of a child criminal in the US is laughable. Policy and Practice, 1 1 , 71-89. Dictators have been turning kids into fighters and weapons for the war. But bringing them to justice is a complex issue. Since 2001, the participation of child soldiers has been reported in 21 on-going or recent armed conflicts in almost every region of the world. Are child soldiers against the law? Last, The kids go through irreversible trauma so they could never normal again Should Child Soldiers Be Granted Amnesty? Some families die due to the violence, while other children are taken or come willingly and are brainwashed and drugged into thinking that what they are doing is normal.