Jared diamond guns germs and steel thesis. Guns germs steel thesis statement Free Essays 2022-10-28
Jared diamond guns germs and steel thesis Rating:
5,1/10
277
reviews
Jared Diamond's book "Guns, Germs, and Steel" presents a fascinating and thought-provoking thesis about the factors that have shaped the modern world. In it, Diamond argues that the differences in power and technology between different societies are not due to inherent differences in the abilities or intelligence of their people, but rather to the presence or absence of certain environmental factors that allowed certain societies to thrive while others stagnated.
According to Diamond, the key factors that contributed to the rise of some societies and the decline of others were the availability of domesticated animals, fertile land, and access to the benefits of trade. Societies that were able to domesticate animals and cultivate crops on fertile land were able to produce more food and support larger populations, which in turn allowed them to develop more advanced technology and expand their empires. Those that were unable to do so remained small and isolated, and were unable to compete with the more technologically advanced societies.
Diamond also points out that access to trade played a crucial role in the development of societies. Those that were able to trade with other societies were able to access new ideas, technologies, and resources that they would not have been able to obtain otherwise. This, in turn, allowed them to continue to grow and thrive, while those that were isolated remained stagnant.
One of the most compelling aspects of Diamond's thesis is the way it challenges traditional notions of racial and cultural superiority. Many people have historically argued that certain races or cultures are inherently superior to others, and that this is why some societies have been more successful than others. Diamond's argument, however, suggests that these differences are not due to inherent differences in people, but rather to the presence or absence of certain environmental factors.
Overall, Jared Diamond's "Guns, Germs, and Steel" presents a compelling and thought-provoking argument about the factors that have shaped the modern world. It challenges traditional notions of superiority and provides a new perspective on the ways in which different societies have developed over time.
Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies > Air University (AU) > Display Review
Was it because people in one place were smarter or more determined or in some way better than other people? This allowed them to build larger and more complex societies. They had geographical advantages that allowed them to develop agriculture first. Less Lethal Weapons Essay 450 Words 2 Pages Weapons are deemed as a significant element for military strategies all over the world. . But more often, he is using them as representatives of outdated ideas that his work is arguing against. The Spanish Conquistadores tried to the Incan leader, Atahuallpa, to convert to Christianity but it failed so Pizarro then captured Atahullpa.
Analysis Of Jared Diamond’s Theory In In Guns, Germs, And Steel: [Essay Example], 1164 words GradesFixer
Diamond disproved Summary Of Guns Germs And Steel 466 Words 2 Pages In the book, Guns Germs and Steel, Jared Diamond attempts to answer questions of conquest, such as why Eurasia conquered the Americas, and not the other way around. He believes the answer to western dominance lies in geography and the spread of guns, germs and steel. Specifically how does Dr. From his own criteria, China should have been the dominant power and bound for worldly conquests given its many advantages. More recently, we have seen people argue that whites are not biologically superior, but that their culture is more adapted to gaining wealth and power than other cultures are. He says that some areas were luckier, geographically speaking. Domestication and raising of livestock exposes humans to animal diseases and increases the spread of lethal germs and diseases.
Eurasia happened to have an abundance of edible material because of the right environment leading to the domestication of plants and animals led the people to settle down in one place instead of being nomads. Cite this page as follows: "What is the thesis of Guns, Germs, and Steel by Jared Diamond? Therefore, geography, not culture or individuals, acts as the ultimate determinant for success. Clearly, it has resonated beyond the classical scientific circles into the social sciences, political realm, and business. That number is 20% out of the 15 million americans that have a concealed weapons permit. Our lord permitted that your pride should be brought low and that no Indian should be able to offend a Christian. While Diamond provides solid ideas relating to the conquest of the New World, he often uses his scientistic background loosely with unclear supports forgetting other historical factors that Outline Of Guns Germs And Steel 541 Words 3 Pages Chapter three of Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies by Jared Diamond is a story about how Francisco Pizarro, the Conquistador, brought the end to the Inca civilization with only two hundred men. Next, he uses scientific evidence, especially from biology, geology, geography, and archaeology to make arguments about the prevalence of different types of domesticable plants and animals in different regions and how local climates and geography affected the development of civilizations.
Guns, Germs, and Steel by Jared Diamond Plot Summary
Because of this luck, they developed agriculture and, thereby, became rich and powerful. Smallpox also played a big role in weakening the Inca empire, it made the soldiers and people weak and there were less of them. In certain parts of the world, humans began pursuing agriculture because the fertile soil and temperate climate made agriculture a good use of time and resources. This would limit the risks of putting a weapon into the hands of someone that has harmful intentions. Diamond wonders how the Europeans could have so much power and advanced technology while the rest of the world was still hunting and gathering. The rise of civilization in the form of agriculture helped some societies, notably Western European ones, rely on wheat as a consistent protein source. As a result, agricultural societies developed more new technologies than hunter-gatherer societies, and passed on their innovations to neighboring agricultural societies.
What is the thesis of Guns, Germs, and Steelby Jared Diamond? I think the thesis is that a country's outcome is determined by its geographical...
In Part Two, Diamond talks about the dawn of agriculture and explains why it arose in certain parts of the world, but not others. He argues that the rise of agriculture and the abundance of food surpluses were the key impetus to societal evolution because they spurred technological advancement, economic development, and solidification of political units to manage resources. He investigates various topics such as the availability of domesticable plants and animals, the barriers to travel to encounter and trade with cultures at the same latitudes, and other characteristics of natural resources and environment to argue his main thesis, that it was differences in external environmental factors, rather than intrinsic superiority, that led certain civilizations to become wealthy and powerful. The Incan people outnumbered the Spanish men by 200 to about 80,000, yet they managed to capture the Incans leader. He argues that Europe emerged as a dominant global force because it had a head start in all the things that enable the development of complex, advanced technologies. Diamond also draws upon a wide variety of scientific evidence.
This meant that new crops and new technological innovations could easily spread from place to place in Eurasia. Domesticated animals provided milk, fur, meat, as well as the ability to feed off leftover crop beds and create dung to fertilize future crops. Some places had more propitious climates, soils, domesticable flora and fauna, and other factors that facilitated the development of settled agriculture. In Mesopotamia, ancient humans used trial and error to learn how to plant certain large seeds in the earth, resulting in crops that could be harvested and converted into highly nutritious foods. Diamond said that there were Indian nations living under the rule of the Inca that did not want to be there. He mentions that it obviously has nothing to do with hard work or natural ability, as there are both smart and less intelligent and hard-working and lazy people in all cultures and regions.
What is Diamond's thesis in Guns, Germs, and Steel?
We should not get rid of the right to carry a concealed weapon though there are exceptions depending on the person and their history. For one a person could become mentally ill and could cause harm to others. Rational, logical thinking acts as its own argument. Others have argued that his approach to history elides many of the themes—contingency, agency, and human decision-making—that are fundamental to the discipline. In contrast, use of writing in the Americas was confined to the elite in a small area of Mesoamerica. In other words, some say that Diamond's view seems to suggest that a people's environment determines everything else about their development, from their culture to the technology they develop. It seems China's detour from destiny is over—a puzzle Diamond simply cannot answer in his narrow explanation for societal development based on geography.
What is Jared Diamond's thesis in Guns, Germs, and Steel? Specifically how does Dr. Diamond explain the development of European economic, military,...
Agricultural societies then gained tremendous advantages over non-agricultural societies, because the increase in leisure time enabled people to develop technologies and centralized political structures, and the proximity to animals gave people immunities to deadly diseases. In other words, how does Diamond explain the patterns of world history? The thesis of Diamond's book is that, in the words of the author: History followed different courses for different peoples because of differences among people's environments, not because of biological differences between peoples themselves 25. Jared Diamond explained that the Inca lacking a system of writing did not make the Spanish superior either, although they were able to communicate so efficiently because of it. In the beginning of the book, Diamond has several questions that he wants to find out the explanation for. This is true for a number of reasons. The development of agriculture enabled Eurasian peoples to settle, creating dense, stratified societies who developed sophisticated technologies.
