Disadvantages of mother tongue based multilingual education. What are some disadvantages of the mother tongue? 2022-10-19
Disadvantages of mother tongue based multilingual education Rating:
Mother tongue-based multilingual education (MTBMLE) is an approach to education that emphasizes the use of the students' first language, or mother tongue, as the primary language of instruction in the early years of schooling. This approach is based on the idea that students learn best when they are taught in their first language and that it is important to preserve and promote linguistic diversity. While MTBMLE has many potential benefits, there are also some disadvantages that should be considered.
One disadvantage of MTBMLE is that it can be difficult to implement in practice. In many countries, there are a wide variety of languages spoken, which can make it challenging to find teachers who are fluent in all of the different languages. This can lead to a lack of qualified teachers, which can negatively impact the quality of education that students receive. In addition, MTBMLE requires resources such as textbooks and other teaching materials to be translated into multiple languages, which can be expensive and time-consuming.
Another disadvantage of MTBMLE is that it may not prepare students as well for success in a monolingual society. Many countries and institutions operate in a single language, and students who have been taught primarily in their mother tongue may struggle to communicate and succeed in these environments. This can limit their opportunities and hinder their ability to participate fully in society.
Additionally, MTBMLE may also have negative effects on the students' proficiency in the national or official language of the country. Research has shown that students who are taught in their mother tongue tend to have lower levels of proficiency in the national language, particularly in reading and writing, compared to students who are taught in the national language from the beginning. This can put them at a disadvantage when it comes to taking exams or applying for higher education or jobs.
Finally, MTBMLE can also be divisive and contribute to linguistic and cultural tensions within a community. If certain languages or groups of students receive more resources or attention than others, this can lead to feelings of inequality and resentment.
In conclusion, while MTBMLE has the potential to promote linguistic diversity and improve student learning, it also has several disadvantages that should be carefully considered. It is important to weigh the potential benefits and drawbacks of MTBMLE and to find ways to address these challenges in order to ensure that all students have the opportunity to succeed.
6 Advantages and Disadvantages of Multilingualism
At the same time, individuals who pursue a multilingual educational opportunity experience lower levels of fear and anxiety while being less likely to experience a mental health disorder. Despite this, it is still argued whether students should be required to learn another language in order to graduate. Reading scores in English were somewhat higher than those in Sepedi, probably because there was a greater range of books available in English and children chose to read more in this language. The issue of the influence of the act of teaching in the native language has triggered rigorous debate among academic experts, teaching personnel and the general public. But in a multilingual country like India, establishing an official language was not an easy task. While learning a new language is very difficult it makes students think harder; it pushes them to try something different which they then carry over to their other classes.
Advantages And Disadvantages Of Mother Tongue Teaching
The lack of access to digital learning content is deepening inequalities, marginalization and exclusion. Once you are successful in learning your first new language to become bilingual, it is much easier to become multilingual. The respondents were teachers purposively selected from the suggested pilot schools of Mother Tongue - Based Multilingual Education MTB-MLE in Baguio City. Knowing multiple languages can make students more likely to get better jobs and have a better understanding of the world. Even though there are times when having a conversation might feel strange, the ability to communicate on a personal level in multiple cultures is an advantage that can put you on the road to success. Our country needs to be able to develop and adapt in order to grow with the times.
Strategies and Problems Encountered by Teachers in Implementing Mother Tongue
In general, most students grow in the condition of native language and they prefer learning in the mother tongue. Target learners of Mother Tongue-based Education IV. However, children learning a second language in the early teens It can learn faster and learn the lesson faster also. Tan describe the varieties of languages and the type of person who tries to understand when there is someone whose English was not their first language. Some people see the effort to speak multiple languages as a desire to create open borders in their country, so they oppose any effort to speak anything other than the first language.
While speaking about her book, she communicates through educated language until her mother entered the room. In South Africa, the majority of children are educated in an African home language from Grade R until Grade 3, switching to English in Grade 4. Advantages of Using The Mother Tongue — L1 in the ESL Classroom Advocates of this view would argue that, when learning another language, translation is a natural phenomenon. Many students struggle with learning a language for various reasons. Points and ideas about Mother Tongue-based Education Language is one of the valuable gifts which have been passed to children. List of the Advantages of Multilingualism 1. Or they use their mother tongue even when they are perfectly capable of expressing the same idea in English.
In most countries, the majority of students are taught in a language other than their mother tongue, which compromises their ability to learn effectively. If you do not have Internet access at home or your connection is slow, then you might find yourself forced to rely on local instructors who can help you to begin learning a new language. Four out of six key informants believed that the disadvantage of teaching Mother Tongue-Based Multilingual Education is that some students rely on their mother tongue. Today, the high school graduates are required to study foreign language in schools as it becomes a requirement for them to graduate from certain college with minimum of two years of learning foreign languages. You can travel with more convenience because you understand what others are saying.
In severe situations, being multilingual could cause some people to become isolated from their communities because there are viewed as being an elitist. Tan's intended audience are people who are unaware of people like her mother's limited English who are taken advantage of in everyday life. There is a certain logic to this behavior because it creates a level of privacy for that conversation if most other people in your community do not know what is being said. Knowing what you are ordering at a restaurant, asking for directions to a specific destination, or requesting a recommendation are all much easier when you can speak the local language instead of trying to use Google Translate. Another finding shows that, mother tongue hinder effective communication among students in class.
Resources like LingoHut can help you to become conversationally fluent without a cost if you have a data connection, but even then, self-discipline is necessary to continue using the secondary language fluently. Some problems encountered by the teachers in implementing mother tongue — based instruction include absence of books written in mother tongue, lack of vocabulary, and lack of teacher-training. Bilingual education opportunities encourage brain growth, trigger student concentration, and reduces the amount of time required to transition between task switches. All throughout this article Tan uses personal experience from her mom to show the readers the struggle while also using primary sources to back up her claim. Hence, they are qualified to enroll in high school for elementary level passers and to enroll in college The Importance Of Learning A Foreign Language considered as an official language, which creates an opportunity for the citizens and immigrants to not only study English, but also inherit their mother tongues and learn other foreign languages as well, particularly during the secondary education. What are the advantages and disadvantages of mother tongue education? All that you need to do is speak all of the languages at home regularly. It also allow one to rely on their skills and enhance their cognitive skills.